#305 | When Therapy Becomes a Religion | Matthew Loftus

Has Therapy Culture Changed the Way We Understand Ourselves—and the Church?

We live in a world where nearly every struggle has a diagnosis, every discomfort is labeled trauma, and personal well-being has become one of our highest priorities. But what happens when the language of therapy begins to shape not only how we understand ourselves, but also how we understand the Christian life?

In this episode of Ministry Deep Dive, Travis Michael Fleming and Jami Staples sit down with Dr. Matthew Loftus, author of Resisting Therapy Culture, to explore how therapeutic thinking has quietly reshaped our understanding of identity, suffering, responsibility, and discipleship.

Is ordinary sadness now something to be treated rather than endured? Have we confused emotional health with spiritual maturity? And has the church begun to see itself more as a place of therapy than a community of discipleship?

This isn’t an argument against counseling or mental health care. It’s a conversation about what happens when therapy becomes a worldview—one that promises healing but may leave us less equipped to face the ordinary difficulties of life.

Together, we explore what the church can offer that therapy alone cannot: meaningful relationships, shared suffering, spiritual formation, and a deeper understanding of what it means to be human in a broken world.

Perhaps the church doesn’t need to become a better therapy center. Perhaps it needs to rediscover what it means to be the church.

Join us for a thought-provoking conversation about suffering, healing, and the hope of becoming whole in Christ.

Takeaways:

  • We argue that therapy is a useful tool but therapy culture medicalizes normal life and harms agency.
  • We must set clear boundaries and seek professional help only when distress significantly impairs daily function and relationships.
  • We recommend churches focus on worship, preaching, sacraments, and community rather than trying to fix every personal problem.
  • We observe that younger people sometimes adopt diagnoses as identity, which can foster dependency and reduce responsibility for moral choices.
  • We teach that suffering can be sanctifying and that God’s presence can sustain people even amid profound trauma, not always requiring therapy.
  • We should distinguish spiritual oppression, biological illness, and social factors by assessing capacity, danger signs, and response to basic interventions.
  • We urge pastors to encourage simple practices like rest, friends, sleep, exercise, and seeking help before prescribing therapy as the first option.

Introducing Apollos Academy

Understanding the world beneath the surface is exactly why we’re launching Apollos Academy.

Apollos Academy exists to train ministry leaders to engage culture effectively. Through courses, conversations, and practical training, we’re helping pastors and ministry leaders understand the forces shaping our world so they can engage their communities more faithfully with the gospel.

Visit apolloswatered.org and sign up for our newsletter to be among the first to hear about Apollos Academy.

Stay Connected

If this conversation challenged your assumptions or helped you see the world differently, share it with a pastor, ministry leader, or friend.

Subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive, leave us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and join our newsletter at apolloswatered.org.

Sign up for our newsletter

Order Travis’s book Blueprint: Kingdom Living in the Modern World.

Join Travis’s Substack, Deep Roots Society.

Donate to Apollos Watered and help make the Apollos Academy a reality!

Transcript
Travis Michael Fleming:

Today's episode is brought to you by the Salva family.

May the Lord keep you safe as you continue to serve him.

Matthew Loftus:

I'm not anti therapy.

I'm anti therapy culture and therapy culture is the medicalization of our normal life, viewing our lives through the lens of medical, illness and therapy.

Language taken out of the context of clinical encounter, right?

Caring for somebody, having a therapist, counselor, psychiatrist, help fix someone's mental health problem.

When we take that language and we take that practice of therapy outside of the context for which it was designed and start to apply it to our everyday lives, then it becomes really toxic and can be harmful to people psychologically.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Welcome to Ministry Deep Dive, where we go beneath the surface to understand the forces shaping our world, our churches and our lives so that we can engage our culture more faithfully with the Gospel.

My name is Travis Michael Fleming and I'm your host.

And as you all know, we live in a culture today where nearly everything is interpreted through the language of mental health, which can be a good thing.

It's been a corrective so often we didn't have any language for that, but now we do.

But has the pendulum gone too far?

Because relationships now are toxic, disagreements are triggering, difficult experiences become trauma, and increasingly even the church has adopted the language and assumptions of therapy.

But what happens when therapy becomes more than a tool for helping people and instead becomes a worldview, really a lens through which we interpret ourselves, our relationships, and even God.

My guest today is Dr. Matthew Loftus, physician and author of Resisting Therapy.

The dangers of pop psychology and how the church can respond, we're going to be exploring along with my co host.

We're trying an experiment here.

Jamie Staples is back, is sitting in the.

Jami Staples:

What's up, y'all?

Travis Michael Fleming:

Yeah, she's in the co host seat for a bit today.

We're gonna have some fun with that.

But together we're exploring how therapeutic thinking is shaping our culture, what it means for Christian discipleship, and whether the church has unknowingly exchanged a biblical vision of human flourishing for a therapeutic one.

Matthew, welcome to Ministry Deep Dive.

Matthew Loftus:

Thanks, Travis and Jami, great to be here.

Jami Staples:

Travis, I feel like before we get started, can we just clarify my actual role here?

You use the term co host, but I think what I'm really doing here is when you guys get all smart and heady and like, expert y, I'm the one that brings it down to the lay level.

Like, I have a question for us normal people.

So Matthew, just know I'm.

I'm the equalizer.

I'm the One that reminds us we got normal people in the room.

Matthew Loftus:

Sounds good.

Sounds good.

I have a. I have a friend like that, and it's.

It's such a blessing.

Jami Staples:

Good.

It's even better when you're married to one.

Right,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Matthew?

I mean, I could tell right now this is going to be an interesting episode.

So let's jump right into the subject, because you're right.

I think we all want to know.

I mean, this language is everywhere today.

What made you, though, want to write this book?

You're a physician and you're talking about resisting therapy culture.

Why do we need this book?

Matthew Loftus:

I have been really interested in mental health, both personally and professionally for a while.

And, you know, I really enjoy providing mental health care for people doing, you know, on the mission field here what I call gorilla bush psychiatry and, you know, referring people to therapy.

Having been in therapy myself, I can definitely see the benefits.

And, you know, I think it's helpful to clarify at the start, I'm not anti therapy.

I'm anti therapy culture.

Right?

And therapy culture is the medicalization of our normal life.

Like you were saying in the intro, viewing our lives through the lens of medical illness and therapy language taken out of the context of a clinical encounter, right?

Caring for somebody, having a therapist, counselor, psychiatrist, help fix someone's mental health problem.

When we take that language and we take that practice of therapy outside of the context for which it was designed and start to apply it to our everyday lives, then it becomes really toxic and can be harmful to people psychologically.

And, you know, especially from the church perspective, kind of what the.

The experience that really got to me and said, okay, this is.

This is really a problem is I was visiting a church in the US and, you know, I don't know what this church is like on other Sundays, but they just happen to be on the Sunday that I was there doing this thing that was like 20 minutes of therapy speak and then like five minutes of talking about the Bible.

At the end, I was like, well, you know, if I want therapy speak, I go on TikTok, but I give to church because I want to hear the Bible.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I've been to that church.

I've been to that.

Jami Staples:

Church.

Right, right.

The one.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I've been to that church.

Jami Staples:

Or the one he's at.

Yeah.

Matthew Loftus:

I was like, this is.

This is.

This is out of control.

And then I also read Abigail Shrier's book, Bad Therapy, and I was like, wow, this is a really important topic.

This is really critical thing to get in.

And she did some good research and Some good interviews.

But overall, the book, I was underwhelmed.

You know, there were just some major issues with it.

And then obviously she didn't have the.

The church perspective on things, so I was like, okay, I got it.

Now this book has to get out there.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay?

Jami Staples:

It is.

Travis Michael Fleming:

It is out there.

And it's.

Jami Staples:

And it's.

It's a little out there.

Out.

You're talking about your book, right?

Your book has to get out there.

It's.

It is a little bit like out there.

Can I just tell you why I think it is so far out?

You are one of the only people that I have read that actually brings the therapy conversation this very close to the word sin.

Like, that never happens.

So I really, really appreciate it.

Yeah, like, people don't do that.

And you dive right into that conversation.

So I just really.

I admired and appreciated that aspect of the book.

Matthew Loftus:

Well, thanks, I.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Gotta say.

Oh, go ahead.

Go ahead, Matthew, go.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, no, just very experienced with both sinning and, and being in therapy, so.

Jami Staples:

Well, you should have gone into that a little more because Travis and I, we don't know.

We don't know anything about the sinning part.

So it was a little complex for us to navigate.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You bring up a really serious question, though.

And I was trying to explain my, My.

The book to my wife, which was never a good thing when I'm trying to do it right before I walk out the door, because my wife wants to delve into it because she has learned a lot over the last few years, talking about neuroscience, talking about trauma.

My daughter finished graduate school and is now a family therapist.

We've had some of these conversations kind of ad nauseam.

What do we do?

Because it seems like everything right now is therapized.

And I'm like, well, is there any human agency at all whatsoever?

What about personal responsibility?

If everything is trauma, we're all traumatized, but we're not.

So you're trying to call us back to that, right?

Is that what you're trying to do, is you're saying, here's the bad, here's the bad.

This is the good that we need to hold on to?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, absolutely.

Obviously, for people of an older generation, right.

People grew up in a time when mental health was very stigmatized, where, you know, people were really shamed for having mental health issues and things like that.

And, you know, I think that there was a very strong push to try to get rid of that.

And, you know, because I think that was bad.

But we have swung so far in the other direction.

That now having a mental illness is for, I think, especially young people, especially very on, you know, very online people, right?

It's like.

It's an identity marker.

It's a tribal signifier.

It's a way of making their.

Whatever.

Frustrations, whatever is going on inside of them legible to the world around and say, like, okay, well, I fit into this box of depression or PTSD or anxiety, and therefore I can have, like a community and people will care about me.

Travis Michael Fleming:

So what do you think then are the proper boundaries?

I mean, let's just get right to it.

What are the proper boundaries?

Cause it seems to me that you're you.

You kind of went after a bit those who say no mental help whatsoever, right?

And then you have those who see a therapy for everything and anything.

And you're saying, okay, now how do we call this back?

So my wife's like, well, what are the criteria?

And I'm like, I don't know, I'll find out.

So what are the criteria?

Let's just get to the meat of it.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

So therapy is.

It's a practice designed to solve problems, right?

So if someone has significant mental health problems, that's affecting their ability to.

That's significantly affecting their ability to love other people in their lives, to do their jobs, to do other things that they have to do in their life, right?

That's when you call in a professional.

That is a.

A good time to see a therapist if someone feels like, okay, especially someone who's really tried.

Because I think one of the challenges is that right now it's like a therapy first.

It's like, well, if you have a problem, go to therapy.

But, well, you know, I think for.

There's a lot of problems.

And therapists will tell you this, right?

There's a lot of problems that people go to therapists for.

They actually just need a friend to talk to, someone that they trust, someone who cares about them, that they can spend time with, you know, someone who can reflect back to them what they're saying and that, you know, exercise better, sleep less time in front of a screen.

Um, you know, I think with the exception of the people who are, you know, having hallucinations or trying to kill themselves, right?

Like, a lot of mental health problems will get better with a couple of these very basic interventions.

And that's, you know, that's not just my opinion.

That's science.

That's evidence based, right.

That these are good things that are good for people.

Right?

But if someone has tried that and they are still, you know, Feeling really bad.

And that feeling bad is hindering them from doing the things that they love and caring for the people that they love.

Then, yeah, then definitely call a professional, see a therapist.

And sometimes a therapist will see someone and say, like, okay, you may not need therapy.

You may need something else.

Right?

And having that.

Just that mindset of like, okay, we.

We want to have therapy and psychiatry solving people's specific problems rather than trying to give them guidance for their entire life.

Right?

Because there's so many other ways, especially right.

Within the church, that we.

That give people guidance for their entire life and how to live.

Jami Staples:

Which actually, I don't know if this is.

Is if this is part of what you're saying, but it reminds me of.

Is this dynamic of trying to qualify what is therapy worthy and what is.

Like, I just really need a solid friend, like you said, who's reflecting truth attributes.

You know, to me, this is the complexity of the matter, right?

Because there's a little bit of.

I actually appreciated.

I think you called it gorilla bush psychology.

Did you.

Did you call it that?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

Okay, so there's.

There's.

In our culture, there's this kind of notion of, like, well, if you're having a series, a string of down days, you probably should call a therapist.

Or sometimes what I see in the church is that's super messy.

You should call a therapist.

Right?

Because I don't know, like, whatever.

And when I spoke with a friend of mine who's from Ethiopia, I was like, what do you guys do?

I mean, therapy's just not even an option over there.

And her answer to me was coffee and popcorn.

Like, we.

We sit and she's being completely serious.

Like, that's what they do every day at tea time is.

Travis Michael Fleming:

We.

Jami Staples:

Come together, we talk through our problems very similar to what you were describing.

So when you say in your book churches are not meant to do what therapists do, I feel like you're kind of.

You're struggling with that pendulum, right, of like, what is therapy and what is solid relationship and community?

And what about these people in this part of the world who don't even have therapy, and yet somehow they're navigating very, very difficult and traumatic things.

Where do you.

Maybe this is what Travis was asking, and I just, you know, needed to bring it down to the lower shelf for me.

But where.

How do you distinguish between what.

What some people can.

Can traverse without therapy and what just needs something else?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, we can break out some textbooks and.

And talk about some Specific definitions of, of what counts as a mental illness.

And sometimes that is helpful.

But mostly by that point, someone is already like, sitting in a professional's office and trying to sort something out.

And especially, like for pastors and ministry leaders who are going to be in many, many, many times, sort of the first point of contact for someone who has these struggles, I think what that person has to discern is like, okay, so how bad is it if it's like you're not showering, um, but like once every other week kind of stuff, or like.

Jami Staples:

Struggling.

Matthew Loftus:

To get out of the house?

There's.

Jami Staples:

Your marker.

There's your marker.

My wife has already told me, like, you're shower more than once a week.

You just heard the doctor.

Matthew Loftus:

Counting, you know, counting the number of Tylenol tablets you have in your cupboard kind of stuff.

Hearing voices.

Right?

Like, that's, that, that is, obviously it's, it's time to call a professional.

But I think again, getting back to the question of agency and responsibility of like, one of the challenges with therapy culture is that it really encourages people to view themselves as sort of like passive experiencers of this thing called depression or anxiety that they can't control, rather than people who are capable of making positive changes for themselves.

And so I think in many cases what someone will have to do in these situations is sort of gently, very gently, kind of push on people and say, well, okay, well, what have you tried to do to help yourself feel better?

Right?

Which is a, you know, can be a tough question for someone.

Sometimes for someone who's like, actually drowning, it's, it, it feels like shaming and, and whatnot.

But it's still like an important question question even for the people who are really in the depths of despair to be like, yes, there is hope because you are capable of, you know, making positive changes for your own life.

So I think in, in those situations, a lot of times it, you know, you're going to have to, to do that pushing.

And if someone says, well, yeah, no, I actually haven't tried any of that.

Maybe I should try that first.

And, and they're able to kind of switch tracks a little bit, I think that that is a good sign that you don't need a professional, at least not yet.

Jami Staples:

And probably one of the key questions that those people in those gorilla bush kind of environments are already asking, because they don't have a choice, like, what.

Matthew Loftus:

Do I do?

Yeah, I mean, I, the, the patients that I see here in rural Africa are the people that for the most part have very Much reached the end of the rope, or they're.

It's, you know, really disrupted their family life and those kinds of things.

And so I. I see the.

The people for whom coffee and popcorn has been tried, and it's not working.

So.

Travis Michael Fleming:

So let me ask you another question.

When I.

When I look at having, like, a missionary encounter, it's more of, like, looking at the culture from the outside.

But with globalization and things that are changing, we're seeing this therapy piece not just a.

A phenomenon of the west, although it's predominantly there, it seems now to be expanding and crossing into the geographical boundaries of cultures that I would say didn't have necessarily passed through the Enlightenment, the Industrial Revolution, Reformation.

Those things.

Usually it goes to the.

Straight to the demonic.

And that's what you've seen play out in a lot of fundamentalist pieces in the United States, in many charismatic circles.

Everything's a demon.

It's always a demon.

It's a demon, it's a demon.

How do you then hold that tension?

Because there is that spiritual idea.

You talk about it in the book, where you talk about this idea of people being oppressed.

How do you then develop criteria to separate between mental illness, the spiritual forces at work, and then even our fallen nature, or the.

Or the powers of the world system that just seem to be coming at us all the time?

So you're going to solve all of our problems right now, Matthew, just right.

Matthew Loftus:

Now.

I mean, you know, what you're describing is absolutely true.

Obviously, like I said, the patients that I see tend to be, you know, of that more exclusively spiritual mindset.

Right.

The problem with anxious people is that they don't pray enough.

PTSD isn't real kind of thing.

There's still a lot of shame around mental illness.

But among the young professionals that I occasionally see as patients, but more often I'm working with as learners already starting to see this stuff filter into their world through social media.

And even one of my colleagues, one of the other family physicians, teachers at our hospital was like, well, it's like when someone brings up mental health, then it's like, sacred, and you can't challenge them on it.

You can't push.

Like, there's no.

Travis Michael Fleming:

It's a trump card.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, it's a trump card.

And.

And you can't.

Can't resist it at all.

So I think when it.

When it comes to dealing with all of, like, all the different factors, I don't think it's always possible to separate them out.

And so I usually work more.

More from a Basis, let's say this less assumption that there's one thing causing this and more like, okay, so of the possible inputs here, which one do I think is less likely to be happening?

Right.

I'm just assuming that most people, Right.

Because we are holistic, integrated beings.

I don't know if you read Matthew Lein's what's the name?

The Logic of the Body.

Right, Logic of the Body.

Great, great book.

But just thinking about, you know, where there's so many pieces, we, you know, it's easy to, you know, we think about like body and soul, right.

And those are big ones.

But then you think about like someone's character, someone's community, right.

Spiritual forces working on them, the environment that they live in, their appetites, their desires, their spiritual walk with God.

Right.

That there's so many different ways that our mental health can be affected that I, that I, as a, as a practitioner, as a thinker, as a writer, I just want to say, you know, okay, so when, when someone comes in and they have, you know, serious depression or anxiety or something like that, I, I'm just going to assume like, okay, there's prob.

Sort of physical, genetic, neurobiological thing going on.

And there's probably also some social element going on.

And I'm sure there's a spiritual element going on with that.

And just saying, like, okay, it's all here.

What, what kinds of things can I fix with the tools that I have?

What sort of things am I and my institution able to do for this person?

What am I able to encourage this person to do for themselves?

You know, I'm very fortunate to work in a context where not only a spiritual care, sort of part of the deal at a mission hospital, but also in a, In a cultural context where people tend to come to any medical visit with their spouse, with their kids, with someone, even a neighbor sometimes.

And so I'm able to bring in that social element as well to help people, which is really fantastic.

A privilege that many people in western contexts don't have.

Jami Staples:

Yeah.

And also the transverse or converse of that is.

You talk a lot in the book about capacity and you have this.

I kind of refer to it as.

We're like triune beings, right?

The body, soul and the spirit.

And sometimes we just don't have the capacity to attend to one of those elements.

In the United States, we know your nutrition can play a big part in your mental health.

Well, you don't really have the luxury in various parts of third world countries to talk about.

Listen, you need more Orange juice, you need more vegetables, you need more protein, right?

Like, that's just not an option.

And so being able to minister to them with the resources and the capacities that they have seemed like super important in that discernment of how to come and how to approach, which I think translates to, even to what we're doing here in the West.

Like, each person that I come in contact with doesn't have all the resources that I may have.

And so when I'm talking about, do I deal with this as a physical complexity or do I deal with this as a spiritual complexity?

Well, that person can't change their physical environment.

They don't have the resources or the capacity to do that.

So what I can do is invite Jesus into this space or vice versa, or whatever.

You have such a good.

I'd never heard of Catherine Greene.

McCreet.

Is it McCreet?

McCrate.

I'm.

Matthew Loftus:

Not sure.

Jami Staples:

You mentioned her in your book.

Am I a sluggard then?

This is her story.

This is her story of depression.

Am I a sluggard then?

Is my disease making me a sinner?

I find it hard to believe that a biological deficit in my brain could make me more of a sinner than I already am.

But I cannot turn over on my bed.

I lie motionless on my left side.

How can the fact of sloth caused by depression be considered in itself a sin?

Man, that is so hard, right?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah,.

Jami Staples:

So hard.

What do you think is the base root of what she's wrestling with right there?

Matthew Loftus:

What she's wrestling with there is the fact that our spiritual lives are.

There's.

There's so many things that affect our spiritual lives, right?

We are not just like little brains on a stick.

We are not little souls on a stick.

That things in our, in our brains, our relationships with other people, you know, the, our past decisions and of course, you know, spiritual warfare going on around us.

Like all these are things that can tempt us or strengthen us, right?

There's, there's a lot of hope there and that there's a lot of different ways to help people get better.

Um, but when it comes to these temptations to sin, they are, it's.

It can be a really heavy burden and a real struggle for people to choose the right thing when they're really sad or really anxious.

And obviously there's a feedback loop there, right?

Of right.

If I, if I feel depressed and I choose to self medicate that by staying up late playing video games or, you know, drinking alcohol, another very popular thing, right?

That, that will, number one, make Me feel worse.

Number two, it will make it harder for me to choose, well tomorrow night.

Right.

Because I've, I'm.

I'm habituating myself to this pattern of choosing the wrong response.

And yeah, it's really tough to break out of that cycle and it's really tough to, to live with that.

But that's, you know, what, what we got to do in order to get better.

Travis Michael Fleming:

As we're talking about therapy culture, what assumptions about human nature does therapy culture really teach us to accept?

Let's break that down a little bit.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

So I think a lot of the, kind of, the biggest assumption is that all of life is meant to be understood in terms of achieving a therapeutic out.

So it's like healing in and of itself is the healing once being healed, being therapeutically saved, as it were, from whatever internal psychological issues you're experiencing.

Like that is the, that is the highest good.

And so all other goods are subordinate to that.

And anything else in your life has to support that.

Now it's easy to get it mixed up because obviously, like, this is a theme in the Bible, right.

God is a healer.

Jesus healed people.

For thousands of years, Christians have talked about our, our redemption or salvation as a, as a kind of healing from the sickness of sin.

Right.

And this, there's things in, in Jesus ministry that reflect this in the teaching.

So I don't want, you know, so I don't want to like, cast aspersions on all that.

Right.

I am a medical missionary.

So, like, this is also my day job.

Right.

Is to heal people in Jesus name.

So I dig it.

I'm into it.

But when that sense of healing becomes the most important thing and it becomes the, the primary paradigm by which people judge institutions, judge their relationships, it can become destructive to not only our own internal mental health.

Right.

But also our relationships and institutions and things like that.

Jami Staples:

So if being healed is not.

Then our ultimate achieve.

Yeah.

What did you say?

The, The.

The most therapeutic outcome, Right?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

As believers, healing plays a different role.

We've got a different outcome that we're looking for.

What is the relationship between the healing process and name that outcome?

I think we would all agree, but I just love for you to say the outcome that we're looking for is what.

And the purpose of healing is promoting that outcome in what way?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

So the ultimate outcome is experiencing communion with God.

Right.

Being loved by him, loving, loving him in return.

And healing obviously serves that right in.

And even good mental health.

Right.

Serves.

Serves that.

I don't want to downplay the role of good mental health in that.

Because when, you know, our mental health is rightly ordered, then we are better able to, you know, love other people, serve people, relate to God in a healthy way.

Obviously there are ways in which, you know, I think about religious ocd, for example, as a, as a perversion of the, you know, people want to love God and yet their, their mental health has been impaired and twisted in such a way that their, that that desire, rather than feeding the goodness of responding to God's love, becomes just this hamster wheel of anxiety that causes perpetual distress in that person's life.

So yeah, so I think having good mental health absolutely serves that.

You know, I think we have to be careful about the language of finding who you were created to be.

Because even though, right, God has put these things inside of us, right, these desires and these ways of relating to him and the world that are good and you know, it takes time to, to refine those and, and build those up.

And um, but certainly the, the quest for perfect mental health sort of works against itself, right?

The more that you think about like, how good do I feel about myself and how, how, how good are things on the inside?

Right.

The, the more that, that, that kind of becomes slippery and you start to think about the ways in which things are not good.

And.

Yeah, and certainly if, if people come to believe that their self actualization or whatever desire inside of themselves needs to be satisfied in order for them to be complete, right.

Like there's a lot of different ways that we can lie to ourselves about what it is that our mental health needs in order for us to be happy or fulfilled.

Jami Staples:

Reminds me of that.

Humility.

The humility is not thinking less of yourself, but thinking of yourself less.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Yeah,.

Jami Staples:

Yeah,.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, exactly.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, historically people understood themselves through categories like virtue, vice, duty, sin, obligation and community.

But today we're using these new categories of emotional health, psychological well being.

I want to know, in your opinion, what have we gained and what have we lost in that trans.

Transition?

Matthew Loftus:

I think what, so what we have gained is for people on the, on the far, on the further edges of the spectrum, you know, the people who are suffering from mental illness that we have gained the, the language and the capacity to help them rejoin normal society and live life without some of the intense, you know, distress and despair that, you know, they otherwise would have been suffering with.

And I think we have given, we've given people language and a way of thinking about themselves that when it's in step with the Spirit, with the Holy Spirit and submitted to God can You know, really provide some profound, you know, builds that capacity for them to serve people.

You know, like my ability to serve as a medical missionary, I think has, has been helped by some of the language of mental health and some of these, you know, group therapy things and, and some of the introspection and, and stuff like that.

But what we've lost is a normal path for people that aren't out here, right?

Like for people that, that aren't suffering, that the, the language and the practices of therapy that are designed to fix problems, when you apply them to a normal person's life, then they just tend to create problems.

Right.

And, and that, you know, we see that, for example, in these school mental health screening programs that are trying to get teenagers to talk about their feelings in ways that often magnify those feelings and make them psychologically sicker as, as time goes on, as the, you know, as research is now showing.

Jami Staples:

And it sounds also like you were saying in your book that one of the other things that's lost, very similar to what you were just saying, is the notion of agency.

These things are not happening to me.

Correct me if I'm not understanding your book correctly, but these things, all of these terrible things are happening to me and therefore I am the way I am.

Matthew Loftus:

Exactly, exactly.

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well then when we look at that, is there really a danger that ordinary human experiences that we have, grief, disappointment, anxiety, conflict, even discomfort, are increasingly being interpreted as conditions requiring therapeutic intervention?

So here's the question.

Who or what determines what a healthy human being looks like in a therapeutic society?

Matthew Loftus:

Well,.

Jami Staples:

That's a good question.

It's a good question, Travis.

Matthew Loftus:

It is a good question.

Two.

Jami Staples:

Points for you.

Yes,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I'm winning.

Matthew Loftus:

I mean,.

Jami Staples:

No, you're not winning.

You're not winning.

You just got two points.

Matthew Loftus:

A lot of it is, is kind of submitting to rule by expert.

But then a lot of the self appointed experts are just influencers on social media who have no idea what they're talking about.

You know, they just make something up and then everybody runs with it.

Then, you know, people just start repeating this misinformation and so they think that, like, okay, well, gosh, you know, I'm not going to, I'm not going to date a man unless he's in therapy.

Like, what is that?

Like, is that really, you know, I think that's.

Have.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You heard that.

Matthew Loftus:

Going to work out well for if, if it's practice at scale, you know, and.

Jami Staples:

It's practiced at scale.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Have you.

Jami Staples:

Actually.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Heard of someone doing that?

Matthew Loftus:

You could, you could find.

I mean,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I know.

Matthew Loftus:

Exactly how you search for it, but it is a, it is a sentiment you see if you scroll enough.

Yeah, because the.

Jami Staples:

Implication is like somebody's only proactive about their self care or, or they're only mentally healthy if they're in.

Matthew Loftus:

Therapy.

Jami Staples:

Right, there's that undertone.

It's true.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah,.

Jami Staples:

It's true.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Yeah, so, so that's, that's.

Yeah, so.

So it's the, you know, people submit themselves to what the experts say and some of those experts are just lying.

But even for the ones that are based on like solid scientific evidence.

And I do want to say that like, you know, there's plenty of good information on social media about, you know, good practices for mental health and whatnot.

But even that is still like not enough of a.

What science and research about psychology has told us is not really enough to tell us about who we are, the purposes that God created for us, and, and how to live a, a fulfilled life that is oriented to the goods that, that God has given us.

Travis Michael Fleming:

That leads me to my next question because as you just mentioned, really, you're talking about the imago dei.

We're created in the image of God.

We've, we all understand that we've fallen in sin, we've been redeemed in Christ and called into communion with God and others.

Right.

With the church.

We know that.

But how does that understanding of the person differ from the anthropology implicit in therapy culture?

Jami Staples:

Whoa, timeout.

Whoa, lower shelf.

Person calling in an audible here.

Can we rephrase that question?

Like I need to hear that question again.

I'm sure it's also worth two points.

I just don't know because I don't understand the words you just said.

Can you try to.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay, here we go.

So we know that we come to salvation in Jesus, right?

We're created in God's image.

Most people forget about creation, that we are created good in the image of God.

But we did fall into sin.

So many people focus on the fall that they forget that there's creative good.

But we know we've been in redeemed in Christ.

We've called into communion with God.

And you actually talk about union with Christ in your book, which I really did appreciate.

But that idea of us being made in the image of God, the imago dei, we've been redeemed some.

And you actually allude to this a little bit in the book Matthew, then they don't know what to do with the struggles of mental health.

Like, it's like anthropology is different for them now it's like, okay, we're redeemed in Christ.

And it's almost as if they don't have any problems anymore.

It's like, no, that's not real.

Read the Psalms for crayon out loud.

You know, people are still struggling.

So there are some people that get saved and they, they become a follower of Christ and they don't know what to do when they keep struggling with this mental health kind of thing.

So the idea is in therapy culture, yes, it's almost got this idea that we, we do have a fallen nature and they almost forget the redemptive part.

But yet how do we juxtapose the two?

Does that help?

Jami Staples:

I, I think so.

And I think Matthew's gonna answer the question that's gonna help me understand the question better.

Go ahead, doc.

Travis Michael Fleming:

There we go.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

So there's, there's a couple of different strands that, that come together with therapy culture.

Some are older than others.

And so again, it's, it's like the idea that there is a. I think probably the most important one is that.

And, and you get, if you read like Carl Truman's Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Explains a lot of the show.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, I know.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Yeah.

So there you go.

Yeah,.

Matthew Loftus:

You guys can go, go back to that episode, right, that, that people have this inner self that has a certain desires that must be satiated in order for you to complete yourself.

Right.

And, and to become therapeutically healed.

Right.

Or saved.

So that, that's, I think the, I think that's, that's kind of this, the standard view of human life and human flourishing.

And in that story, then the, maybe the evil or the fallenness is internal, but often it's very, it's external.

Right.

Like they, I think for a lot of, of people who are kind of Wisconsin therapy culture, the story is you were created or you were born good, and then your parents and society and traditional religious strictures or whatever capitalism made you, traumatized you, and that caused you to develop these various mental health problems and develop these diagnoses.

And now the way to be saved from whatever condition you feel is to consume, self, medicate and pursue whatever it is your desires are.

And then once that's, once those are fulfilled, then you can be redeemed.

And there's sort of this, you know, this two sides thing of like people wallow in misery, right?

Because that gives them a sense of identity.

It lets it, you know, they kind of inhabit.

They live to the worst of the diagnosis, but then they also, you Know, are constantly trying to like suppress any bad feelings, you know, and self medicated through con.

Conspicuous consumption or various addictions, things like that.

So that's, I think kind of the, the at its very worst, that's, that's the anthropology of therapy culture.

That's what people have, the pit that people fall into, the lie that is sold to people.

And you know, I think the, the Christian answer is.

And by the way, the power is flat.

Like I might, the, the power might go out.

I can switch over to a cell phone if need be.

But just.

Sorry.

Travis Michael Fleming:

About that.

Jami Staples:

That's, that's T.I.A.

They say, right, this is Africa.

That's just.

Matthew Loftus:

Yep, yep, yep, this is Africa.

Jami Staples:

That's right.

Matthew Loftus:

So, you know, and, and the Christian counter to that, right, is to say like, yeah, you were created good, but we all fell, right?

We are all responsible for our own sinfulness.

Like, people may have done other things to us.

Society certainly could have.

You know, there's, there are these social forces that make things worse.

There are forms of oppression, you know, and then there's sometimes there's church communities that are harmful.

Parents make bad decisions.

Some parents are better than others.

And those are all things that, that can affect us, right, and make life harder for us.

But rather than trying to medicate away every bad feeling or you know, kind of remain stuck and wallow in this, in this sense of like, woe is me, I'm a perpetual victim, right?

Like that redemption we have in Christ and the work of the Holy Spirit in our hearts gives us a renewed sense of capacity and agency that now we are able to respond to all those terrible things in the world and even those terrible things in ourselves in a way that has been transformed and empowered and that gives us hope, right?

Because now we're not stuck with like all the bad things that other people did to us and all of the bad feelings we have, right?

That there's a, there are ways to overcome that.

And you know, again, professional help and medication, psychiatric medications are part of a balanced holistic journey and in capacity and growing in agency for some people.

But for, you know, for everybody else, you know, there, there is the life of the church, there is union with Christ, there is the work of the Holy Spirit, you know, and then there's solid practices of, you know, just having good friends and fellowship that, that sustain those things for us.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Do you think that it's possible that we've subtly replaced holiness with wholeness?

Jami Staples:

Holiness?

Travis Michael Fleming:

Holiness,.

Jami Staples:

What exactly.

I'm calling it automatically.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Holiness.

Holiness.

Jami Staples:

Holy.

I was like, oh, are We.

Another theological term I'm not familiar.

Travis Michael Fleming:

With.

No.

You know what?

Hopefully, you know what holiness is?

Jami Staples:

Holiness.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Holiness and wholeness.

Jami Staples:

Cole.

Got it.

I'm with you.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Have.

Have we subtly replaced holiness with holiness?

No, we've very explicitly replaced it, I think, in many cases.

Jami Staples:

What does that mean?

Explain that to me.

Matthew Loftus:

That the.

The vision of what a Christian life, what a good Christian life.

The.

The encouragement and the.

The goal that we aspire to within the church is now wholeness.

Right.

As defined by whatever, you know, the culture tells us it means to be mentally healthy with some Christian language kind of painted on, as opposed to holiness, which is, you know, living righteously, overcoming sin, union with Christ.

And, you know, I think the distinction is.

Is really when it comes to suffering, that, like, in the Christian life, we recognize, like, that God uses suffering for good, and that suffering is an invitation to draw near to him rather than something to, like, always suppress and it's always bad.

And, you know, either it's.

Either it's something that needs to be medicated, or it's oppression that has to be rectified.

And.

Jami Staples:

Can I drill down in that for a minute?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, please do.

Jami Staples:

Because I'm one of those people that teaches wholeness as the epitome, but the epitome of the outcome.

Because wholeness is what happens when we have the communion with God that you were talking about earlier, wholeness in the word shalom,.

Matthew Loftus:

Right?

Sure.

Jami Staples:

The original way that God intended is wholeness.

Right.

So holiness.

I guess I'm gonna push back and say, I don't think maybe this isn't what you guys were saying, but I don't think holiness is the goal.

I think holiness gets us to the goal.

Holiness.

The goal is Eden.

Right.

Because that's where we're headed.

That's where we came from, and that's where God is restoring us to.

And wholeness, by the definition of shalom, my identity put back to the way God intended and being able to enjoy that Eden kind of relationship, communion with Him.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

Not only produces holiness, but when we obediently enact holiness, righteous behavior, we actually achieve.

Am I, like, pushing way off, or are we kind of saying the same thing, different words?

Matthew Loftus:

I think there's a subtle distinction, and I think part of.

I mean, one of the challenges is how we define wholeness.

Right.

Because if you do have that rich theological definition that gets you 95% of the way there.

But I do think.

And this could be a whole another hour conversation, and.

And I really like.

Jami Staples:

We got time.

It's only, it's only 3 o' clock here, it's 11 o'.

Clock.

But Travis and I are, you know, and this.

Matthew Loftus:

Is a, I, I go, this is where I, every year with our new family medicine residents, actually, this is where I go with them.

And it's, and it's a lot of fun having these discussions is that we will not see that wholeness in its completeness in this life that we, we cannot get back to Eden here, right?

And that the right and, and Christian hope, right, The Holy Spirit is the down payment on our inheritance in heaven.

That we, we have this guarantee of what's to come and we have this longing for what's to come and we have this work in the world of moving to.

Right, Sanctification is moving towards that.

And certainly holiness in terms of our full transformation into the likeness of Christ and full unity of Christ is also not something that we get here.

But I think that when, when people are working towards wholeness in a contemporary culture, holiness is not part of the equation for, for getting there.

And so I think where the danger is for the church is not necessarily that like people are going to have their, their doctrines like, contradicted.

It's more that if there's an aspect of Scripture or there's a doctrine or there's something that is like pushing back against that, you know, the, the more standard, broader cultural definition of wholeness, something that contradicts that, something that's offends or what have you, that, that become, that that's off limits, you know, and, and it's.

So it's perfectly okay to talk about the Bible and to talk about how God heals us and to talk about how, you know, God makes us feel better, right?

Those are all good things.

Like, these are all things that are, that are in scripture that are celebrated throughout Christian history.

But if you, if you, you know, the, the example I like to talk about is sin is that like you can take, you can talk about sin as brokenness, right?

Or you can talk about it as a rupture in the relationship.

And those are true things, right?

Those are real dimensions.

That is not, you know, modern people making stuff up out of the Scripture, right?

But if you go, right, but those are facets of the truth.

And if you step over here and you talk about this other facet about like, you know, sin is violating the law of God, like, okay, well, can't go there, right?

That's not an acceptable.

Yeah, so that, that was a, that was a lot in response.

And you know, I, and I I do appreciate the face, the pushback because I think, you know, we're, we're moving in, in many of the same directions, but I do think some of those little distinctions are, are important.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I, I have a follow up question.

You, you talked about suffering a little bit ago.

How should we distinguish between suffering that needs treatment and suffering that calls for pastoral care and suffering that is simply part of faithful human existence as taking up our cross and following him.

Jami Staples:

Another two points for Travis.

I'm interested.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Too.

So winning today.

Jami Staples:

You're killing it.

He's.

Matthew Loftus:

Like,.

Jami Staples:

It is too late for these kind of.

Matthew Loftus:

Questions, man.

I'm like, this is, man, if I, if I knew the answer to that question, I would, you know, have a,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Have your show,.

Matthew Loftus:

Have another book.

There's, yeah.

And I mean there's, there's a lot of good books about, about Christian suffering and so that's, there's plenty to, to engage there.

But I think a lot of it is just like just showing up and being faithful in the small things that you've been called to, no matter what.

Travis Michael Fleming:

A lot of obedience in the same direction as Eugene Peterson said.

Matthew Loftus:

Yep, exactly that.

You know, and you know that we're starting to go through that book with our oldest daughter and I, and I do love the way that he just kind of walks through, you know, the psalms of ascents and those are, you know, that's a rich text for just like, for dealing with all these different kinds of suffering even.

This is how we, we look up to the hills, right?

We look to God and wherever we are.

And there's times when we are like, just being comforted by God and then there's times when like, other people are oppressing us and we have to like, push back and fight back against that and ask God to, you know, bring his wrath down.

And I think it's, you know, going back, I think, to the very beginning of this conversation, you know, a lot of it is just sort of defined by like, okay, if, if this suffering in your life is profound enough that it is inhibiting you from doing the things God has called you to do and to loving the people in your life, then yeah, it's, it's time to call a professional.

But then even after you've called the professional, you still have to do the thing that everybody else has to do, which is, you know,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Get out of bed in the morning,.

Matthew Loftus:

Call us.

Yeah, get out of bed in the morning.

Right?

Persevere, Take a shower, persevere.

And what God has called you to, like, resist the temptation to just, you know, constantly scroll or to withdraw into yourself or to snap at somebody because they irritated you.

There's a. I don't know if you read Alan Noble's book on getting out of bed, but it's just the very best thing.

Travis Michael Fleming:

About.

Matthew Loftus:

Oh, has he.

Okay.

Travis Michael Fleming:

He's also been on this show.

Matthew Loftus:

Oh, man, you guys have great guests.

We.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Do.

And this is the apex right.

Jami Staples:

Here.

Matthew Loftus:

Very good.

You know.

Jami Staples:

What, Matthew?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

You.

You have.

As you're talking about suffering, there's another vignette in your book, and I won't read the whole paragraph because it would take forever.

And also, I'll probably cry if I try to get through it.

But Helen Reservir, a missionary.

Travis Michael Fleming:

In.

Jami Staples:

The Congo.

Yeah, a missionary in the Congo, was raped by rebel soldiers.

And this is what she says about that experience.

I think it just.

Travis, I'm just bringing it up because you're asking about suffering that needs therapy and suffering that.

Like, where do we.

And here she is in the midst.

Like, it is happening to her.

The worst suffering, one of the worst sufferings is happening to her.

And this is what she says.

And suddenly there was God.

Didn't see a vision.

I didn't hear a voice.

I just knew with every ounce of my being that God was there in all his majesty and power.

He stretched out his arms to me.

He surrounded me with love.

Like, it doesn't make sense to me.

To me, this is like your gorilla bush psychology.

Like, this makes no sense why this should work.

But in that environment, that is literally all she knew, is that he is present.

I don't understand why just his presence, like, it didn't stop the situation.

The horrible suffering was still happening.

His presence healed her even as it's happening and allowed her to learn how to cope with that story of her life.

It is mind blowing to me.

And I think that, for me, is one of the things that is missing from therapy culture is the belief that he can do that and just his presence can do that kind of work.

It's.

It's like if we say that somehow we're diminishing the work of therapy, you know, of.

Of good counsel and all.

It's not.

But really good therapy understands this principle of presence.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

And Christian.

Really good Christian therapy is gonna understand the beauty of God's presence in a place of pain like that.

Yeah, I. I could go.

I could rant for a long time, but I will not, because then I'll lose my points.

I haven't been given any points.

You haven't given Me.

Any points?

No, no, no.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You got points.

You got 10 points just there.

10 Points just for that right.

Jami Staples:

There.

Okay, so I'm.

Travis Michael Fleming:

An arbitrary point total there.

Jami Staples:

Such a good story, Matthew.

I'm so glad you included that in your book.

Travis Michael Fleming:

And it's a hard one to digest, I think, for a lot of our people.

That leads me to another question, though.

Can a person be psychologically distressed and yet spiritually mature?

Conversely, can someone be emotionally well adjusted but spiritually unhealthy?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Great.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Jami Staples:

Like, I think that's me.

I think that's what you're describing.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Which one?

Jami Staples:

I mean, at times, depends on the day.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

So.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

No, go ahead.

Did you want to elaborate on that?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah, no, no, you go ahead.

Jami Staples:

It's like, not just, yes, that's the answer.

20 Points to Matthew for the most concise answer of the day.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You know, one of the things I actually did appreciate.

I mean, I appreciate it a lot about your book.

It's not easy to explain to someone, though.

I told my wife, she wanted to know really what it's about.

And the arguments that I get into my wife when I try to explain a book, and she's an audio learner and I'm a reader, and I just, like, I give her the snippet and she wants the whole thing.

And.

And if I only give her the snippet, I don't fill it in.

She wants more.

And so.

And I can't give it.

So we get into this discussion.

So I was trying to explain to her the book, and I was like, there's those who basically deny any aspect of therapy.

And you actually bring up the counseling, which I thought was very interesting.

And I'm not throwing out all of them, but I do know that there is a certain segment that just says you only need the Bible.

And then you got those tribal people, you kind of pray and.

And you.

You do all of those things.

And then there's the group that says everything is therapeutic and they lose the biblical language.

And you're saying, no, there's good that we need from therapy, and there's some.

A lot of bad, and we have to learn how to sift the two.

Am I right in that?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

Good.

Yeah, I would.

I think that is.

I mean, my.

My hope is that the people who are just like, you know, PTSD is fake.

If you're anxious, you need to pray more.

My hope and prayer is that people who are like that will pick up this book and find their views challenged and, you know, encouraged to.

To broaden what they're thinking.

But of course, obviously I'm also writing for people who are kind of like, well, what is going on?

How is all this therapeutic language, like, affecting our ability to preach, teach the Bible, and walk with God?

Travis Michael Fleming:

I want to look at this concluding chapter that you have, the Good enough Church, which I really did appreciate because the church does play a role, and all of this and healing and community and pieces like this.

And so one of the things that you said, though, and as a pastor, having been a pastoral ministry for over 20 years, I want to give these little five little bullets you gave when you said, a good enough church exists to worship God, celebrate the sacraments, and preach the word.

Amen.

A good enough church doesn't exist to fix people's problems.

Number three, a good enough church is a place where leaders and others live in healthy cycles of stress and rest.

A good enough church is a place where people mourn and lament together.

And five, a good enough church doesn't have a steady stream of wounded people limping out.

Why did you put those five in there?

And why is that so important for us?

Matthew Loftus:

So I put those five things in there because I felt like I, I needed to have something practical in the book.

The book is very much focused about conceptual clarity and helping people think about, like, what is happening.

And especially, you know, thinking about the audience of parents, pastors, teachers, mystery leaders, like, the things that people are saying to them.

Because I think, you know, every pastor wants to care for their congregation and they want to communicate the Bible in a way that makes sense to people.

And so it is perfectly logical and good to try, you know, in a.

In a culture that is dominated by, you know, this therapeutic idiom to, like, communicate the truth of scriptures in a way that people will understand.

But I think there's so many burdens placed on pastors, and especially within this realm of mental health, there's like, so many shoulds just sort of flying at you all the time.

And so what I wanted to do was just like, to narrow down, like, okay, what for pastors, what are the things that are most important for them to.

So that way they don't, like, constantly feel like, this burden of, like.

Well, I can't say this because then, you know, that's going to scare people off.

And I can't say this because that will make somebody else's mental illness worse.

Right?

And.

And I.

But I have to do that.

You know, I have to say.

Say things in this way.

I have to do all these other things and just to be like, okay, like, major on the majors.

Focus on the things that only you as a pastor can do, right?

The, the mandate that God has given to you in your institution, within the church.

And then on top of that, what are the ways to know?

Like, okay, maybe things are not working the way that they're supposed to.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I have this kind of anecdote where you don't want to give all the shoulds to pastors.

And I had somebody ask me one time, they're like, well, what do you need to know as a pastor?

And I was like, what do I not need to know?

I have never had to do anything with thermonuclear dynamics, but other than that, pretty much everything else is in play.

Because I've been asked about building codes, sociology, psychology.

I mean, bailing people out, the criminal justice system, rent, like, you know, people's Social Security, retirement, legal issues, civil lawsuits.

It's like every time I turn around, I'm like, well, didn't study for that in seminary.

Like, I, I, I always tell people, like, I make a joke because you're in Africa.

Because my church, my church went from 95% white to 45% majority world culture, and we had a large population of Africans.

I've done more African weddings than I've done Caucasian weddings.

And we had dowry negotiations at the campus.

And I remember going, I didn't take this class on how many cows the daughter's worth.

Like, that, Come on, there's no.

Jami Staples:

Class for that.

Travis Michael Fleming:

There's no class.

Jami Staples:

For that.

Travis Michael Fleming:

How do you negotiate this?

Like, what's good or bad?

And now we're talking about therapy.

And then you get into, you know, all these other things where couples are like, well, I have this disorder or that disorder, and, or I have this phobia.

And finally I was like, I've got, I have phobophobia.

I'm, I, I'm afraid of phobias.

Jami Staples:

Afraid of phobias.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I'm afraid of phobias.

That's my issue.

Jami Staples:

You know what, Matthew?

Like, that reminds me one other thing that you said that I think you didn't put in your list, but it's a way of adding freedom to a pastor you talked about.

I wish I could just flip open to the page about not avoiding triggers, about the, I think it was the national center for PTSD was talking about actually people having to face, you know, there's context to this, let's be honest.

But in general, pastors being so careful to make sure that we don't say certain words that we don't use certain language, that we don't touch certain topics, things like that, because we might actually activate, you know, people.

And.

And something that you were saying in the book is like, hey, there's actually need for that in the healing process.

It doesn't mean we go, like, harp on people's stuff and.

And be insensitive.

Although I'd like to point out that, like, Jesus totally triggered Peter on the beach.

You know what I mean?

Like, hey, hey, let's ask this question three times.

Like, he's totally tapping on his betrayal wounds.

Like, we're just gonna rip this thing right open.

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah,.

Jami Staples:

But.

But he did that because he knows that in order to.

What's it called when you take.

Doctor, what's it called when you take expressions out of.

Yeah, but I just mean, like, when you've got an actual wound and you're trying to take all the debris out and whatever.

Yeah, there's a word for that.

Anyway, that's what he's doing.

He's like, I have to open this a little bit so that we can take this debris of these lies that you believe out.

And I just think that's hugely, hugely freeing, not just for pastors, but ministry leaders and anybody who's in a teaching role or something like that.

Like, we can't avoid everybody's wounds.

Like, we can't do that.

And in some ways, there are ways to actually bring healing by opening that up and replacing lies with truth.

And I just think that would bring a lot of relief to people in those roles.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I think you also brought up something in the book where you talked about not only the people that have been hurt, but those who have perpetrated that hurt.

I thought that was really interesting when you brought that up, because I have found that people think like it.

I find the opposite where people are.

I need forgiveness for evil that I've done.

But what about the people that you hurt?

You know, what do they need?

But it was good that you address both, and I was.

I was appreciative of that because I think there's so much to that for both.

Both need to have the grace of God.

Both need to understand love and forgiveness and grace and things like that.

But, you know, Matthew, you've.

You've given us a lot today.

I know your time is short.

You're still on call.

It's late there in Africa, although we're just getting warmed up and started.

So what's a concluding thought, though, like a water bottle that you can leave with our audience today?

Matthew Loftus:

Yeah.

That you are loved with an everlasting love.

And because Jesus Christ came into the world, died for you, rose again, you can live a better life.

And he has given you the power to overcome whatever it is that you are struggling with.

And even for people who are struggling with very, very basic things, like getting out of bed.

Right.

Like, if getting out of bed is the mountain that you have to climb today.

Right.

Like that God is there with you, and he gives you the power to do what you need to do and the strength to overcome and the hope that tomorrow you can do even more.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Amen.

That's a good word.

Amen.

Matthew, thank you for being a guest on Ministry Deep Dive.

Matthew Loftus:

Thank you Traveling, Jamie.

It's a great time.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, that was an interesting conversation.

Jami Staples:

Yeah, man.

And, like, I felt like we kept opening doors to conversations, and then we were like, well, we also want to talk about this.

We also want to.

So, like, we only, like, went like, 30ft into so many things that I would just, like, I need, like, eight more hours with that guy.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Honestly, these kind of conversations are exactly why we're launching the Apollos Academy, where we equip pastors, ministry leaders, and just everyday believers to understand the culture that we're living in that's shaping our thinking and engage the world with the gospel.

You can learn more about that@apolloswater.org you can sign up for our newsletter and stay connected with what we're doing.

And if today's conversation has actually helped you, then please share it with someone.

Subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive.

Leave us a rating that actually helps other people find it or a review.

It really does help.

I want to thank Jamie for being my co host today.

Jamie, thank you.

She'll be back periodically.

She has time.

Hopefully you've really enjoyed her insights.

And I think she actually wins the point total today.

So.

Jami Staples:

That.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Was pretty awesome.

Take a blue.

Awesome.

Blue ribbon.

You get the blue ribbon.

We're gonna start throwing it out.

You get stickers.

We're gonna have.

We gotta have a reward system when you come on.

We need to have an established reward system.

Jami Staples:

Money.

I just didn't know if that was a thing.

Thank you for having me, Travis.

It was fun.

I appreciate.

Travis Michael Fleming:

It.

It was fun.

And thank you for watching Ministry Deep Dive.

Stay watered, everybody.