#303 | Has the American Dream Distorted Our Christianity? | Ben Norquist & Brian J. Miller

What if some of the things American Christians believe about land, neighborhoods, property, and even the places we build our churches have been shaped more by American culture than by Scripture?

We rarely stop to consider how the places we inhabit shape the people we become. Yet our neighborhoods, communities, and inherited cultural assumptions influence how we understand the world, how we read the Bible, and even how we carry out the mission of the church.

In this episode of Ministry Deep Dive, Travis Michael Fleming welcomes Ben Norquist and Brian J. Miller, co-authors of Every Somewhere Sacred: Rescuing a Theology of Place in the American Imagination, for a fascinating and sometimes uncomfortable conversation about the relationship between faith, culture, and place.

Together, they explore how American exceptionalism, suburbanization, historical injustice, and our pursuit of comfort and security have shaped the Christian imagination—often without our realizing it.

But this conversation isn’t simply about confronting the past. It’s about recovering a biblical vision of creation, land, belonging, and the mission of God’s people.

What if we’ve become so accustomed to seeing ourselves as the heroes of the biblical story that we’ve failed to recognize the ways we sometimes resemble the Babylonians or Romans instead?

And what would change if churches began seeing their communities not simply as places to attract people from, but as places where God has called them to embody the gospel?

In this episode, we explore:

  • Why American Christians have largely neglected a biblical theology of place.
  • How the American Dream has shaped our understanding of property, neighborhoods, and community.
  • The uncomfortable histories and cultural myths we’ve inherited—and why telling the truth matters.
  • Why the Bible’s story of creation, land, exile, and restoration challenges our assumptions.
  • How suburban life, mobility, and individualism influence our understanding of discipleship and mission.
  • What it means to see land as gift, sacrament, kin, and home.
  • Why pastors must learn to read their communities as carefully as they read their cultural assumptions.
  • How churches can move beyond cultural comfort to embody the kingdom of God in the places they’ve been called to serve.

The central question: Are we allowing Scripture to shape how we see the world, or are we allowing our culture to shape how we read Scripture?

This conversation will challenge you to look differently at your neighborhood, your church, and the places you call home.

About Our Guests

Ben Norquist has worked in Christian higher education, spiritual formation, community engagement, and organizations addressing peace and justice in the Middle East.

Brian J. Miller, PhD, is a professor of sociology at Wheaton College whose research explores how neighborhoods, communities, and physical environments shape social and religious life. He is also the author of Sanctifying Suburbia: How the Suburbs Became the Promised Land for American Evangelicals.

Together, they are the authors of Every Somewhere Sacred: Rescuing a Theology of Place in the American Imagination (IVP Academic).

Introducing Apollos Academy

Understanding our culture requires more than recognizing what’s happening on the surface. We need to understand the stories, assumptions, institutions, and cultural forces that have shaped us.

That’s why we’re launching Apollos Academy—training ministry leaders to engage culture effectively.

Through courses, practical training, and ministry cohorts, Apollos Academy will equip pastors and ministry leaders to understand the culture they’ve inherited, recover the grand story of Scripture, and embody the gospel faithfully in an ever-changing world.

Visit apolloswatered.org and sign up for our newsletter to learn more about Apollos Academy and receive updates as we prepare to launch.

Stay Connected

If this conversation challenged or encouraged you, subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive, share this episode with a pastor or ministry leader, and leave us a rating and review. Your support helps us bring thoughtful conversations about theology, culture, and mission to more people.

Sign up for our newsletter

Order Travis’s book Blueprint: Kingdom Living in the Modern World.

Join Travis’s Substack, Deep Roots Society.

Donate to Apollos Watered and help make the Apollos Academy a reality!

Transcript
Travis Michael Fleming:

Today's episode is brought to you by the Guthries.

May the Lord give you health and peace.

Ben Norquist:

There are multiple land stories about given places, and some of those stories get amplified and some of them get suppressed or contained within small pockets of people for whom that story, like they experienced that story from a different social location.

They were the victims of it, perhaps, and it's something that's uncomfortable for them, but for another reason.

And so acknowledging and telling the truth is actually important for credibility sake.

I mean, just one reason among many why I think it's important.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Have you ever stopped to consider how much the places where you live have shaped who you are?

Think about it for a moment.

The neighborhood that you grew up in, the schools you attended, the places where you worshiped, and even the way your community was designed.

The roads you traveled, the people you encountered, and perhaps more importantly, the people you didn't encounter.

We tend to think of place as simply the settings in which our lives unfold.

But what if those places are actually shaping us in ways we don't even recognize?

And what if some of our assumptions about where we live, what makes a good neighborhood, what it means to own property, or even where we choose to plant our churches have been shaped more by American culture than by scripture?

For those of us in ministry, those are important questions.

Because if we're called to love our neighbors, make disciples, and bear witness to the kingdom of God, shouldn't we understand the places where God has called us to serve?

Welcome to ministry Deep Dive.

I'm your host, Travis Michael Fleming.

And today we're exploring something that doesn't always receive much attention in our conversations about discipleship and mission.

A theology of place.

Joining me are Ben Norquist and Brian Miller, co authors of the new book Every Somewhere Rescuing A Theology of Place in the American imagination, published by IVP Academic.

Ben holds a PhD from Azusa Pacific.

I gotta say it right?

Ben Pacific University, and he's worked with Churches for the Middle East Peace in the Network of Evangelicals for the Middle east, helping American Christians think more deeply about peace, justice, and their responsibilities toward their neighbors.

He's also also worked in spiritual formation and community engagement at Bryan College and with the center for Faith and Innovation at Wheaton College.

Brian Miller has been a guest here before.

He holds a PhD from the University of Notre Dame and is a professor of sociology at Wheaton College, where he studies how our communities, neighborhoods, and physical environments shape social and religious life.

He's also the author of Sanctifying how the Suburbs Became the Promised Land for American Evangelicals and co author of Building a Sociology of Religious Structures.

Together they've written a book that challenges us to reconsider the places we inhabit, the stories we inherited about those places, and what faithful Christian presence might actually look like.

Gentlemen, welcome to Ministry Deep dive.

It's great to have you both with us.

Ben Norquist:

Thanks.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Glad to be here.

Travis Michael Fleming:

This is a book that I don't think too many people think too much about.

But let's begin with the title, Every Somewhere Sacred.

I wanna say every place.

Every single time I say the title, I wanna say Every Place Somewhere Sacred.

No, Every Somewhere Sa.

What do you mean by Every Somewhere sacred?

What is the theology of place?

And why did you feel the need to write this book?

Ben Norquist:

Amazing.

Thanks, Travis.

Glad to be here.

Yeah, that title, it.

It tends to be tripping people up.

Like with the dozen, you know, conversations we've had in the last month about this.

You know, I bet more than half of the time people.

People have trouble with the.

With the title.

The editor, when we were talking about the title, the editor said, I actually really like this title.

Cause it's like.

It's a construction that you don't quite expect.

And so it's like, more memorable.

So that's what we stuck with.

But the spirit behind it, the idea behind it is that God just created the world, the universe, with a particular intention in mind.

And, you know, and it.

And God's relationship to God's creation, we don't fully understand that or, you know, the things that we've believed about this place that we live.

The world, like you said, have been more deeply shaped by our American cultural values and history and legacy than by the Bible.

And that's the need that we see for this book.

The impetus for the book, I think at least, you know, the story behind when we kind of discovered the need for this book is.

Brian and I have different but overlapping stories.

Mine starts, you know, in the upper Midwest, where I grew up in a conservative homeschool community in the twin cities of Minnesota and Wisconsin.

And didn't really.

I wasn't really exposed to the world.

I didn't.

You know, I was in a very kind of homogenous community.

Everyone that I knew kind of believed the same things, had the same basic worldview about this.

This grand place that we call the universe and creation.

But then in college, I started seeing more of the world.

I had a mentor who actually I had opportunities to travel with.

And I ended up in places like Slovakia and Uganda and Cambodia.

Like, different.

Very, very different kinds of places than what I was familiar with.

And in each of these places, I started meeting the church that lives there and seeing the gospel being lived out in ways that were very different and that challenged some of my own assumptions about the world.

And so that was really rich ground.

Then when Brian and I started talking about the sociology of places and you know, and we were taking walks in Wheaton and thinking about the kinds of basic assumptions that our neighbors had about their property and about the suburb and about the world writ large.

And it was out of those conversations then that the vision for the book was born.

Brian J. Miller:

And I'll add here, my experience is more in living in the suburbs.

So that's what I study, that's what I've thought a lot about.

But I think when Ben and I were having conversations about locations, we wanted to write something broader that wasn't in the genre.

That's often in the theology of place, where somebody picks a particular kind of community, type of community, and says, here's the issues, here's what Christians can do.

And so the answer sometimes of those books is, well, you have to leave one place to go to another, or there's some places that are better than others, given our history and our context.

And we wanted to write a book that sparked imagination across all of these contexts.

So less of a question of are there ideal places where God would have us live, but rather if we're in these communities already, God has put us there for a variety of reasons.

How do we contribute to the well being of the people and the communities and the earth around us and take that physical, material reality seriously, wherever we're planted?

Travis Michael Fleming:

Why do you two think that American Christians don't really have a good theology of place?

It's not something that's top of mind.

Ben Norquist:

So in the book, I'll just really briefly, in the book, we talk about kind of half truths that we believe and, you know, that are rooted in the legacy and in various histories that we inherit, you know, and where a lot of the kind of ideas, worldview about place and location and land is forged.

And, you know, we go all kind of all the way back to the settlement, the European settlement of the United States, and really bad ideas that Europeans were carrying with them about the land that they were arriving in, you know, that they were kind of like a new chosen people arriving in a new promised land that God had promised to them.

And so like, who are these others who already live here?

Like, less than.

They were less than and not inheritors of that same gift.

And we talk about histories, you know, coming forward of the way that land has been kind of mapped onto racial categories as well as.

And like, there are all of these.

And it's not all, you know, quote unquote, bad histories or bad ideas, but we, we are tracing the kind of development of some of these half truths through these, these experiences that we, that we have been deeply influenced by and our worldviews about land have been influenced by.

And then we just, like, lay them next to Scripture.

So we spend a whole chapter in the, in the book, kind of revisiting Scripture.

And when we revisit scripture, asking these questions about land, we're doing it in conversation with some theologians and some thinkers who we think, you know, are thinking really well about it.

Brueggemann is the one that often comes up.

Walter Brueggemann's thinking about land in themes in the Bible, but also alongside indigenous Christian, you know, Native American Christian theologians who are thinking from within their worldview as well as they read scripture about land.

And, and so.

And then the answer is like, bottom line, there's a big gap between a lot of these inherited ideas in the American church about land and what we, what we find in Scripture when we go back with fresh, fresh questions.

Travis Michael Fleming:

That was one of the things that, when I was reading your book, I didn't know what to expect.

Most Christian leaders aren't talking about land.

They just don't.

It's an assumption that everyone just takes in.

And most people that I know are just trying to survive.

How do I continue on?

They're not thinking about it.

And then when they do, the question then becomes, what do I do with it?

Like reading about how indigenous peoples were basically just, I mean, ripped off the land in Georgia by Andrew Jackson was horrific.

And what he did, and they didn't do anything about it.

And he basically challenged the Supreme Court because they said it was wrong what he was doing, but no one did anything about it.

And my mentor, for those that don't know, was the first white man ever to be trained to be an indigenous medicine man.

So he would tell the story about the Trail of Tears.

So we would talk about a lot of these different things that we would go and visit and serve at reservations, seeing the conditions, seeing what was going on, seeing the poverty.

It's one thing to be in all suburbia and your nice suburb or whatever it is where you're at.

It's another thing to see this and go, how did we get here?

And it's so many white Christians think, oh, it's their Choice.

No, no, it's not.

It's not.

So this theology of place really does occupy a part in our imagination.

But one of the ideas that you explore in the book is really us living in a place without knowing it.

What does that mean?

Brian J. Miller:

So many of us in the United States, Christian or not, as you noted, Travis street, land or place is a background issue, a background variable.

Right.

We do our things, but most of our activity we don't really think depends on our communities or the physical soil or the things around us.

Right.

I was thinking as Ben was talking about these American half truths we call them throughout the book, these land stories that Americans tend to tell that we would say, when you look at the Bible, those are not the land stories that God has.

Right.

So these ideas like exceptionalism or frontiers or generating wealth, God sees land as fundamental to the human story, the whole story of creation in ways that we as American Christians say it just doesn't matter.

Right.

It doesn't come up.

And what we were hoping to do with the book is, you know, we get to the end, we don't have easy answers for people.

If you sort of do this, this, and this, here's how you'll be better at addressing place or land.

But, Ra, why don't we go back to that biblical story and say from the beginning, throughout the whole text of what God's been up to, land and place matters.

God cares about these places and land and people.

Right.

It's not an either or.

It's not.

It's people over land.

It's not land over people.

This is all of creation that we think Christians should pay attention to.

Right.

We should be asking about this.

We need to have that conversation.

We need to spark imagination without just offering an easy answer at the end of, well, do these two things and you're suburban or urban or rural community, and, you know, you'll have addressed it.

Travis Michael Fleming:

That was the one thing.

Oh, sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you, Ben, but I just wanted to say that was the one thing when you said you don't give easy answers.

That's why I got mad at the end of the book.

I was like, what is the answer here?

Ben Norquist:

Did you get mad at us?

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, you guys did a lot of critiquing, and I appreciated the narrative, but I'm like, okay, what?

What do I do to give my people?

Ben Norquist:

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

And my wife and I were going back and forth, and she's like, it's perspective.

You've got to have a different perspective.

And you can't have A different perspective till you understand the stories of other people.

Of course, my wife is the words of wisdom, which I don't want to admit publicly, but she is.

She's definitely more the.

The wise one that's there.

But.

Ben, you were going to say something.

Go ahead.

Ben Norquist:

Well, yeah, I mean, and actually fits into your conversation with your.

Your wife as well, which is just that our.

Our beliefs about land often turn out to be beliefs about people who we imagine living on that land as well.

And I mean, this is where we get into some of the critique of the ways, the unjust ways that we tell land stories as American Christians, that you can see it a lot in a lot of discourses that are considered to be kind of political and sensitive, like discourses about other countries and the people who live there, discourses about immigrants and migration, discourses about this place or that place.

And often, if you think about it, like, what comes to mind when we tell these stories?

Like, the one I often think of is Appalachia, where I was growing up in the Midwest.

If the topic of Appalachia came up, there would be these images and these ideas that would come into our heads that don't necessarily correspond to reality.

They're kind of caricatures.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Yeah,.

Ben Norquist:

Stereotypes.

Yeah, they're stereotypes.

And the ways that we told those stories about that place, Appalachia, turn out to often be pretty insulting to people who live there.

And so it really is, like, when you kind of take that step and realize, oh, what?

Our imaginations are not our own, they actually belong to God.

And God expects, like, it's a part of our discipleship actually, to be cultivating an imagination that is, you know, animated by God's imagination for a place and a people, not by the various, like, other interests that we often allow to shape our imagination for other places and people.

So it's pretty practical on that level in terms of our character and our moral character as people and the kinds of stories we tell.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, even those stories that we tell, they reinforce the narrative of what we believe and who we believe ourselves to be.

They actually form that.

That's why it's so important to do cultural apologetics.

For us, that's the work of establishing the Christian message, but it's through having a right voice, conscience and imagination.

So how we sound to the culture, how do we understand evil when it's occurred, and how do we respond to it?

And I think too often we have individualized so much of salvation that we don't want to think about those other things, because then we Recognize we might have a moral responsibility for that.

And then we want to know.

I mean, that's the issue that we have going on in our culture right now.

One of the issues, Am I morally responsible for the choices that have gone before me?

I am a recipient of land and I live in a place that I don't know the history of it.

I mean, I know some of it.

I've read some of memorials and I haven't gone and done my due diligence.

I never even thought about it till I was reading your book.

And so it makes me stop and go, okay, what does that mean for me?

And what does that mean to these pastors and ministry leaders out there who have very little time and they're trying to figure out how to disciple their people who probably believe some of these myths and stories.

So what you're saying and you're advocating for is, okay, let's just put it up to light for a moment of scripture.

Let's see what the actual scripture actually says.

Because instead of the scripture forming us, we've let these myths color our viewing of scripture, not vice versa.

Correct?

Ben Norquist:

Well put.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Thanks a lot.

All right.

That was a great show, fellas.

Brian J. Miller:

Well, you asked a little bit earlier, Travis, about how do I study a community, right?

How do I know a land or a place?

And this is a theme running throughout the book of how do you read what's going on around you?

And most of the time we're just blind to it, where we aren't paying attention and we don't know what to look for.

But we argue this is a skill any of us could develop.

This is we have God given capacities to see.

Why is it this way?

Why is it not this way?

What are the stories we spend a lot of time in the book talking about, what are the stories that we could recover of others who have lived here or who also live here, that we don't hear, that we don't know, that we tend not to pay attention to or privilege.

Some of that's, I would say, relatively easy to do.

Some of that you can do online, you can walk around, we can look, we can talk to people.

But it would take some focused time of saying, it's important to me to know this place.

Right?

It's not just a set of people who might be transient or moving.

There's something worthwhile to know about this place.

But we also suggest that there's things we can do to be how we can be and how we can act as well.

So it's not just an academic exercise of, you know, let's study the history and the background.

But we need to be the kinds of people then who respond to place and land as God would respond to place and land.

Also skills and habits that we can cultivate and develop.

Travis Michael Fleming:

So here's my question.

I was working with a church, and I read their.

The biography that they had of their church on their website.

But the story of their biography was not true.

It was true as far as the people putting the website on staff knew.

They weren't trying to be deceptive, but that's the story that they had themselves.

I went back and I did a deep dive and I found out that the church had started actually a significant time ahead of that, but the history wasn't good.

So they chose not to tell that history because it's uncomfortable to deal with the choices of the generations that have gone before and to know what is my moral responsibility and culpability for choices I didn't make.

But I'm the recipient of some of the things that we received.

How do we as Christians come to terms with that?

What is our moral responsibility and culpability in dealing with this kind of thing when we hear about these injustices that have taken place?

Ben Norquist:

Yeah, I mean, so one of the premises that we're operating with is that those stories that have been buried, it's important for them to be told, for them to be brought out from where they've been hidden.

And, and that itself is a step towards, you know, it's a good step to take telling the truth, even when it's uncomfortable.

I think about a professor I had who talks.

Who talked about.

He was a theology professor who was talking about just these kinds of things, like the way that.

That institutions, maybe people sometimes narrate their legacy and that we, we just kind of assume, oh, yeah, this is where you, like, boast.

But.

But we have these really dark, troubling aspects in our legacies as well.

And that is also very important to, to tell the truth about.

And one, just one of the reasons is credibility between groups.

So the story that was buried by that church, there are.

There's probably other communities who tell that story regularly from a different perspective.

And then when they see the church not acknowledging the story, it damages the church's credibility.

So, and this is where, like when we're in the chapter where we talk about this, we.

We talk about that there are multiple land stories about given places, and some of those stories get amplified and some of them get suppressed or contained within small pockets of people for Whom that story, like they experienced that story from a different social location.

They were the victims of it, perhaps.

And it's something that's uncomfortable for them, but for another reason.

And, and so acknowledging and telling the truth is actually important for the, for credibility sake as well.

I mean, just one, one reason among many why I think it's important.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Not a lot of our people out there are historians.

They're not sociologists.

They're not looking at that intensity intensely of things.

They're for many of them, just trying to figure out how to connect to their people.

But again, this is where the environment helps and where you come from.

And we're not just talking about city or town, which is part of it.

And you guys go through a whole history of that.

I mean, you talk about sett from the 13th colonies and indigenous populations and how the land actually was acquired and going through it, which was very, very fascinating.

There were a lot of things that I just didn't know, some things I did know, but I think it'll be very eye opening for people.

And I liked how you tied it back into how does God work with land?

Now let's talk about that for a minute.

Why do so many Protestants have such a low theology of place?

Ben Norquist:

Brian, you want to take that one?

Brian J. Miller:

Yeah.

That is a big question.

Right?

And.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Hence the silence.

I, I don't know, it was, I was like, wait, is, is this thing on?

What's going on?

So, I.

Brian J. Miller:

Mean, a lot of this motivated why we wrote the book in the first place.

Ben and I had worked on some projects together right before we had started writing this book.

We had looked at the locations of a lot of the, the Christian colleges and universities in the United States, sort of asking why are they where they're at?

And it found many of them are sort of in suburban or rural areas, they're not in big cities.

And started thinking like, what's the logic behind that?

Right.

Why would communities that would want to reach people would want to train future generations, why would they locate in these particular places?

And we, we were continually struck by theirs.

The logic that Christians in the US tend to be using is not Christian thinking and logic.

It tends to be American ideals here.

And we've lost some sense that place matters.

It's maybe it's a dualism, right?

We don't really think that our bodies and physical things matter.

It's more about our souls or our brains.

We live in a society and culture where we're transient, we're mobile.

Americans have this idea you can go anywhere Right.

You can choose.

Right.

This is my individual choice.

If you've got some resources, I can go anywhere.

As we note in the book, there's a long history that doesn't line up with the biblical story of what God has for land and place.

Even getting people interested in the topic is difficult.

Right.

Because our book is more like, you have to have some interest in it to some degree to say, oh, now what would I do about it?

Right.

Or start asking those questions.

As a congregation, what's our responsibility to our community when.

Yeah, sure, congregations have all sorts of other interests and things they could be pursuing, but we're suggesting this is essential to what Christianity is.

God cares about people and places together.

He wants to restore people and their souls and their bodies and their hearts, and he wants to restore places and creation at the same time.

Ben Norquist:

I think back to some of the more tectonic, even in the deeper past of industrialization and what that did to people's relationship to places and the Enlightenment and what that did to people's worldview about creation.

You know, there was a kind of loss of enchantment, like this world.

There's this, like, spiritual world behind this world and interpenetrating with this world.

Like, there's this sense of we can be masters of this world, you know, through science and reason.

Some of that stuff is at play as well.

But also, when I think about Catholic theology around, like, the sacredness of church spaces and the altar and how that changes, and access to God is not through a particular place.

It's through faith alone, wherever you are.

My mom talks about I can be as close to God praying in her car as she can be sitting in the pew of her church.

Some of that kind of Protestant shift in thinking about where we gain access to God is also certainly at play in all of this.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I think also, of course, and you talk about this, that Christ is the temple, he's the greater temple, but yet then we become temples, which you guys didn't mention.

And I was waiting for that part, unless I missed it.

I mean, I did read the book, just so you know.

I read the book.

Ben Norquist:

Okay, because you got mad at the end.

So we know.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Yeah, well, I was mad.

I was mad because.

Well, because I wanted.

I. I wanted to more of a. I wanted more of what do I do with this?

Like, there were some pieces that I really wanted to know about.

Because I do think you're onto something.

I think there is a cultural idolatry in place.

And I know, Ben, I'm not as familiar with You.

But I am familiar with Brian's work and looking at suburbia and some of the social structures.

And in his last work, and especially being from Chicago, seeing how that white flight took place and their denominational headquarters went with them, that led us to stop and go.

So many of our theological tribalism is not theological as much as it's.

Or it's just as much ethnic as it is.

Like, you don't get a lot of black Lutherans.

I say that because it's much more ethic.

They're German covenants, are Swedish evangelical free.

So it's about belonging and having that identity or that assimilation thing is what you guys mentioned in the book.

There's like smaller assimilation groups or affinity groups, that kind of thing, I think.

And so I'm just wondering again, borrowing your language of a cultural toolkit that we need to have in order to do this.

Well, because I'm looking at it going, okay, yes, we have a theology of place, but we're in a rootless culture right now.

I think it was a term that's been used, the gyro vague.

We just flow from place to place to place without any rootedness anymore.

So I'm saying I don't think, no offense to your book, I don't think that's going to change that anytime soon.

As you mentioned using a squirt gun to charge and try to do this.

But yet I think it's a very important part of the conversation because we have to ask what are the idolatries that are implicit within those narratives that we've assumed and lived out of that affect our Christian life?

Now, that's what I want to know.

And I know that you guys are more from a sociological perspective, but is it possible then, in light of that for a church to be deeply committed to, like evangelism and discipleship while remaining largely unaware of the cultural assumption shaping the community which it and which it ministers?

Brian J. Miller:

I'm thinking of one of the texts we use with our students here at Wheaton in our first year seminar, Christopher Wright's book about the mission of God or the Great Commission and the mission of God, where he argues the five marks of mission for Christian are teaching and discipleship, or evangelism and discipleship, which many Christians are familiar with, but adds justice, compassion and creation cares.

These consistent themes in scripture that often churches see as maybe not as necessary side projects, maybe good things to do.

But you, you know, you focus on the key things first.

And this argument there is again to read the whole story of God acting in the world is to acknowledge all five of those parts of mission and our participation in it.

That we lose something essential by just focusing on one or two of those and highlighting them and saying, well, creation care doesn't really matter.

Right.

Or it's something that's ancillary.

We're missing what God is paying attention to.

Sorry, Ben, I cut you off there.

Ben Norquist:

Yeah.

I also just think about.

I think the importance for.

Or where it can get practical is in matching our understandings and our approach as churches, as ministers, as people who want to connect with and bring the love of God to the places where we live and inhabit, is acknowledging some structural facts about those places.

And that.

That.

That is.

That definitely, you know, there.

There's, like earlier when you were talking about people who look at Native American reservations and.

And make an assumption about, oh, they're choosing to be there.

Okay.

So that's a discourse that's a part of someone's imagination about that.

That does not match reality.

And I think that when we minister out of a worldview that is shot through with those kinds of assumptions about the place where we are ministering, it affects our quality of ministry.

It's like we're misdiagnosing people's situation when we allow those ideas about the place where people live, which is such an important part of who people are and their prospects for life and their quality of life and all of that.

Their experiences of life is so determined by where they're born and where they grow up.

And so it is important for the pastor to reckon with, let's say, in a given neighborhood, the fact that 50 years ago or 70 years ago, the government paved over that neighborhood in order to bring the freeway through.

And what does that mean then for the nature of this place and the experiences that people who live there call that place home have had of life.

And if I just, like, kind of, like, set all of that aside or think, oh, that's ancient history.

It's not relevant anymore.

And.

And put in its place these ideas like, oh, they're just choosing to be there, then it speaks.

It kind of loops back in my mind to that kind of credibility gap that results when we make those kinds of assumptions.

Instead of saying, actually, it's very important for me to understand these things.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I'm reading Leslie Newbiggin's autobiography right now called Unfinished Agenda.

And in it, he's chronicling his involvement with global missions and being at a conference with so many of these global missionaries.

And basically he was talking about American theologians and the missionaries were just skipping over the lived experiences of so many different people who needed to talk about justice and oppression and those things.

That was their everyday reality.

And the Americans just wanted to skip over it because that's not their issue issue.

That's not the issue that they're facing.

Whereas other people, when you're in the majority, you don't have to think about what the minority is dealing with.

You get to define the cultural narrative.

But when you start to hear of those other people, because last I checked in the scripture, and I believe anyone who really wants to obey the scripture were to take care of the most vulnerable among us, those who are struggling, who are hurting, who are going through a difficult time, no matter what their background is.

But we need to hear their story so we can able to help them in that tangible reality of what they're experiencing.

Is your hope that your book can help contribute to that?

Ben Norquist:

Absolutely.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, that was great interview, fellas.

You got anything to add to that?

Brian J. Miller:

I'm reminded, Ben, this comes a little bit later in the book, and I might say something about this a little later on, but to me, the pivot of the book is chapter six, where we talk about these different themes for land that might come out of the biblical drama that we tend not to think about where land is gift or sacrament or kin or home.

But in that next chapter, as we're sort of working through those, right?

We present those models and then we say, well, what would we do with those?

How might those help us?

I remember, Ben, we talked about this from the beginning, like in those stories.

What if we just generally, as American Christians are the Babylonians or the Romans in the biblical narrative, right?

We are the oppressors, often about land, right?

We have not used it well, we have used it for our own purposes.

We've exploited it.

We've not used it as God would intend.

And we tend not to read that that way, right?

We see it as, oh, no, no, no, United States is promised.

It's blah.

And yet in the scriptures, it's pretty clear what happens to people who exploit people and land, right?

It does not go well for them in the Old or the New Testament.

And for us to think of ourselves, we could be the Babylonians.

We're the Romans, right?

We're the people coming for judgment and revelation or with the Old Testament prophets.

That's.

That's hard.

Travis Michael Fleming:

And uncomfortable.

That doesn't go with our comfort narrative even.

I mean, we're talking about, like Ruth, when in the book of Ruth where they didn't even glean the fields completely so it would le for poor people.

You know, there's those little stories that you have throughout.

But one of the things I did really appreciate in your book, I'm going to read it here for a second to make sure.

I'm going to put you on the spot here.

But it says, and it was just a quick list because I want people to understand out there, Pastor, ministry leader, wherever you're at, I want you to understand where this is taking place.

Because some of you might be saying right now, where is this in the scripture?

Okay, what are we talking about here?

I'm still not getting what we're grasping.

Why is this such a big deal?

They lay this out for us.

Okay, so let me read some of this for it.

God created the universe.

God made the physical universe with all its spaces and the places that could come to be would come to be.

Yes, we all agree with that.

God deemed the place as good even before Adam and Eve existed.

Everyone nods and amen.

God planted, intended a garden as a special home for people.

Yeah.

After Adam and Eve sinned, God's response included a curse on the ground and displacement from the place.

The garden.

Okay, let's put it down there.

But then is where I really start.

I'm like, okay, I'm with you.

And I'm with you after this too.

But it's.

You started giving me lenses that I hadn't put those two together with land per se.

I just assumed it.

And when you said, like, after Cain murdered his brother, the consequence included displacement to a land of wandering.

Rejecting God's protection, Cain chose to build the city instead of live the life of wandering.

God had pronounced.

Following Cain's template, we see people building many places, walled cities in particular.

In some of the earliest chapters of the Bible.

And the flood was a judgment against the wickedness of a people that wiped out the places that had been built.

The Tower of Babel was a human attempt to attain God likeness that took the form of place building.

You just bring it out over and over again.

When Moses encountered God, he was told to remove his sandals because he was on holy ground.

When God called.

Going back when I skipped over one, when God called Abraham and Sarai to stay away from their homeland, it was to move to a new place, a promised land.

And God dwelled in it.

So you're right.

It's all over the place.

I don't want to read them all.

Even though it was so good.

I really enjoyed that part of it.

I wrote it down.

Ben Norquist:

Thank.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You.

But what do you mean by land is gift, sacrament, kin, and home?

I was like, where are we going, fellas?

What do you mean by that?

Brian J. Miller:

We had read over the years a number of theologians who we'd found helpful in helping us think about land and place as essential God's story.

d, which came out in the late:

I had already been studying suburbs and places, and I'm a Christian sociologist doing this, right?

So I get the sociology side, but realized in my background, the.

The theological side is lacking, right?

My church never talked about these things.

Growing up, thinking about the community, the history, the place.

ike our church was founded in:between the book of Acts and:

That was val,.

Ben Norquist:

Right?

It.

Brian J. Miller:

Was from the Bible to us.

Clear line, right?

And I think that's how a lot of our churches operate.

So when Brugamin makes this argument that actually this.

His argument in that book is the story of the Bible is about land, right?

And.

And then compares it to Jesus's death and resurrection, that's like being gifted land or having land taken away.

This is essential to understanding the people of God from the beginning is God promises them land, but they misuse it, they exploit it, they mistreat it, they don't get it that it's a gift, that they're supposed to use it to bless others.

They only get it when they're exiled, when they're taken away, they're displaced.

And then they're like, oh, yeah, we were supposed to treat the land in a particular way.

God gave it to us to use it this way.

And then they go back and the cycle starts over again.

And he says, this is foundational to the biblical story.

I was like, why have I never heard this?

Why have I never even thought about it?

That that's the.

The land is gift idea, right?

That Christians are to use land to bless others, not to enrich ourselves or to exploit it.

And then we found other thinkers who have done good work in this area as well.

John Inge is a pastor and theologian in England who talks about sacrament.

So can we think of land and place as physical signs of God's grace?

Indigenous scholars, as Ben mentioned earlier, who think about land as.

And place as kin, family, right?

We were created, land was created.

God cared about both.

We were meant to work together, to support each other, to all be restored in the end.

And then the most recent book was Miroslav Volf and his co author there.

Think about land as home.

What if God's the original homemaker?

The plan from the beginning was to make God's home with people, to dwell with his people and creation.

And we find these useful metaphors, ideas for when we often lack for imagination.

What can we grab a hold of?

We found these particularly compelling.

Ben Norquist:

Yeah.

And they're not the only ones.

I mean, we acknowledge that these are just four that we found in our more kind of selective.

You know, the questions we were asking yielded these four.

But.

But they're not the only metaphors that can be found in scripture or themes that can be found in scripture.

About the challenge, the challenge of, you know, kind of merely American myths about what the land is and what it's for.

Travis Michael Fleming:

When you talk about being really invested in places near the end of the book, you talk about being invested in the places where you're at, that we are a transient culture.

We are.

We are moving all the time.

And this is not on.

As we said before, top of mind for many people and especially men and ministry leaders.

But what can ministry leaders take away from your book to help apply in their.

Their local ministries?

Ben Norquist:

Nice.

So I. I will just add to.

We are a transient culture.

I think that we're like a dual culture.

We have a very transient class, you know, tends to be college educated.

They might go to another state for education and meet a spouse who's from a third state and.

And then take a job in another city.

And like, they're very.

They become a transient class.

There's also, in the United States, a.

A group that never leaves their county.

This was true for me in Tennessee, and it really challenges kind of my own assumptions about this society that we live in.

It's much more diverse, complex, and surprising than I believed.

We lived in a cove in Tennessee outside of a small town where I was teaching.

And most of my neighbors there, their parents were born in that.

That cove.

Their parents or grandparents were born in that cove.

And they.

And they were born in that cove and live in that cove.

And going to the big city was going into Dayton, Tennessee, which is, you know, like 10,000 people.

And I really was like, wow, it felt like I was in a foreign country to some degree.

And it really revealed to me the kind of blind spots that I was operating with about who my neighbors are and their relationship to land.

Because so many of us experience life in the United States as rootless others.

They're deeply rooted and not transient at all.

So I think just kind of even that insight and having the ability to step back and say what are my assumptions here about the people that I'm with and their relationship to Land?

I think is a really important starting point.

But then we talk a lot about becoming students of the place and you know, the last two chapters are intended to be like the practical steps, what now Chapters.

And we talk a lot about becoming students of the place and studying the places around us.

That's I think, a really important step.

We also have a whole chapter towards the beginning of the book on reading places like you read a text.

So we all know how to read words on a page, but we don't necessarily have the skills yet for reading spaces and places.

And so we want to cultivate that as well as a way.

I mean, it kind of gets back to cultural apologetics.

It's a way of enriching your relationship to the community that you're in so you can see more clearly.

And seeing more clearly the place and the people around you is I think a very practical, an important capacity for ministers.

Brian J. Miller:

I would add for many people showing up at church on a Sunday, a lot of their practical day to day concerns involve land in place.

How am I going to pay the bills for where I'm living?

Is housing affordable?

How am I going to commute regularly?

The average commute time in the United States one way is about 28 minutes, right?

So I'm spending, average person spending a couple hours a week going back and forth between places.

What does my church have to say about those things?

Right?

How do they help me think about that?

If I'm concerned about data centers, another hot topic in the United States, using up land and resources and making noise like, what's a Christian response to that?

Thinking of a world not just about AI and what it might be doing to us, but these are physical things that could be in our communities.

Does the Bible have something to say?

Does the church have a position?

If people in my community are suffering from drug overdoses, where might they seek treatment?

Is that something we could offer in the community or is that supposed to be elsewhere?

These are physical questions that are we answering in our, in our work on Sundays and throughout the church week?

Travis Michael Fleming:

That is where I found your book was extremely helpful to talk through it.

And you talked about the community.

It was in Itasca where they were going to put the, the, the treatment addiction center for people that are coming off of heroin and how the people responded.

And wait, did it land in a tasket?

No, it's where did it start.

Brian J. Miller:

It started in Wheaton.

They tried to convert open space.

Wheaton said no.

Then they went to another suburb and bought a hotel that wasn't near people's houses and said, this would be even better for our purposes.

It's already segmented into treatment rooms and it won't affect anybody immediately nearby.

And the image that I keep coming back to is the people of Itasca were willing to march through their streets to oppose this drug treatment facility.

It takes a lot to get Americans to actually march in a street against something, right?

A fairly grave injustice that they might think that's coming or some significant threat.

And then you had counter protesters who were standing there saying, no, my family has been affected by this.

We need these kinds of facilities.

And I was struck throughout that whole experience.

And I think it's in court right now.

So it's not ended yet.

But how would Christians respond to this?

Right.

We would default more to our.

Well, my property values might be threatened or how might it fit into my community?

But how would churches think about this?

How would Christians say, is this part of our mission?

Is this the way we should be using land in place?

If it.

It doesn't locate here, where can it be located?

Right.

If we're all practicing some form of NIMBYism and afraid of what might be and who might be in our community, where could it be?

Anywhere.

Travis Michael Fleming:

It's interesting you mentioned that.

And we just did an episode with Jeremy Lundgren.

Some of you may know him, but he'd written a book on a theology of safety and a theology of risk.

And it all comes together.

I mean, you have theology of place, you have safety, you have belonging, you have identity.

All.

All of those things form who we are.

And we have to be able to take all of those under the lens of scripture to say, lord, show us how we are to live in this world in a way that is pleasing to you so that your name might receive glory.

We want to represent the new creation in all of its glory, help us to confront the cultural idolatries that are there and admire and relate to the creational goods that are there as well.

And so it's affirming the good and challenging the evil.

And sometimes that is not always in society, it's in our hearts.

Then we have to be able to do both.

And it's not an easy thing to do.

But, gentlemen, I do want to thank you for your time and thank you for the book to help spur us along in the conversation for those that out there wanted to see it every somewhere Sacred by Brian Miller and Ben Norquist.

Get it at your book tailor near you or just go online and get it on Amazon.

But I want to thank you for turning into Ministry Deep Dive, where we talk about the stuff no one else talks about.

Really, we're trying to get under the surface because we want to see the Lord's name receive glory, and we want to see his name go forth in his kingdom.

And we want to do it in a society that is increasingly deaf to the claims of Christ and who he is.

We want to make sure that we embody it well for the glory of God.

You know, one of the things that struck me about this conversation is just how much of our lives are shaped by assumptions we've never really stopped to examine.

We've inherited stories about our communities, our country country, and even our churches.

And sometimes those stories shape the way we read Scripture rather than allowing scripture to shape the way that we see the world.

And that's a problem, because if we're going to engage our culture faithfully with the gospel, we have to learn to see beneath the surface.

We have to understand the stories that have shaped us, recognize the cultural idolatries that we've inherited, and recover a biblical view vision for what it means to live as God's people in the world.

And that's precisely why we are launching the Apollos Academy.

Apollos Academy is a new initiative dedicated to training ministry leaders like you to engage culture with the gospel effectively.

Through courses, practical training, and ministry cohorts.

We're going to help pastors and ministry leaders understand how our culture has shaped us, examine the ministry ministry frameworks we've inherited, recover the grand story of scripture, and learn how to embody the Gospel faithfully in the places God has called us.

Because the goal isn't simply to understand culture.

It's to advance the gospel and see lives, churches and communities transformed by Jesus Christ.

We're excited about what's coming and we'd love for you to be a part of it.

Head over to ApolloSweater.org Sign up for our newsletter to learn more about Apollos Academy and receive updates as we prepare to launch.

And if today's conversation has been helpful, please subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive, share it with someone you know, and leave us a review.

It helps us get these conversations into the hands of more pastors and ministry leaders.

Thanks again to Ben Norquist and Brian Miller for joining us.

Be sure to check out their book every Somewhere Sacred and remember, the places where God has put us are aren't accidental they're places where we're called to bear witness to the kingdom of God.

Thanks for joining us on ministry.

Deep dive.

Until next time.

Stay watered, everybody.