#304 | Did Christianity Accidentally Create Secularism? | Peter Harrison

What if everything we’ve been told about the relationship between Christianity, science, and secularism is wrong?

We’ve inherited a familiar story: for centuries, humanity was trapped in superstition and religious ignorance until science and reason came along and liberated us. Religion belonged to the past. Science represented progress. And the supernatural? That was something modern, enlightened people had learned to leave behind.

But what if that story is itself a myth?

In this fascinating episode of Ministry Deep Dive, Travis welcomes Dr. Peter Harrison, one of the world’s leading historians of science and religion and author of Some New World: Myths of Supernatural Belief in a Secular Age.

Harrison challenges some of our most deeply held assumptions about the modern world. He reveals how the distinction between the natural and supernatural is a relatively recent development, how modern science emerged from deeply theological foundations, and how Christianity—and particularly the Protestant Reformation—helped create the very conditions that eventually gave rise to secularism.

Even more surprising? The way we understand faith itself has changed. What early Christians understood primarily as trust has increasingly become a matter of intellectual assent and evidence.

And these aren’t merely academic questions.

They have enormous implications for how Christians understand their faith, how pastors lead their churches, and how we communicate the gospel in a culture that increasingly regards Christianity as intellectually unbelievable.

What if the greatest obstacle to believing in God isn’t a lack of evidence, but the way we’ve been taught to see reality itself?

In this episode, we explore:

  • Why the distinction between the natural and supernatural isn’t as ancient or universal as we assume.
  • How Christianity helped lay the intellectual foundations for modern science.
  • The surprising connection between the Protestant Reformation, the Enlightenment, and secularism.
  • Why faith originally emphasized trust rather than merely accepting certain propositions.
  • What the COVID pandemic revealed about our trust in science and institutions.
  • How the modern West came to believe that science and religion are fundamentally opposed.
  • Why people are increasingly searching for meaning beyond a purely materialistic understanding of reality.
  • What all of this means for apologetics, evangelism, and the church’s missionary encounter with Western culture.

Why this conversation matters

We don’t simply see the world as it is. We see it through assumptions, categories, and perspectives we’ve inherited—often without realizing it.

If Christians are going to engage Western culture faithfully, we must do more than learn how to defend our beliefs. We need to understand the cultural framework that determines what people consider believable in the first place.

Peter Harrison helps us uncover that framework and challenges us to reconsider the story we’ve been told about faith, science, and the modern world.

Because perhaps the question isn’t whether Christianity can survive in a scientific age, but whether we’ve misunderstood what science actually tells us about reality.

About our guest

Dr. Peter Harrison is Professor Emeritus of History and Philosophy at the University of Queensland and formerly held a chair in Science and Religion at the University of Oxford. He is an internationally recognized scholar whose research explores the historical relationships between science, religion, and Western thought.

His latest book is Some New World: Myths of Supernatural Belief in a Secular Age (Cambridge University Press, 2024).

Introducing Apollos Academy

Understanding the world beneath the surface is exactly why we’re launching Apollos Academy.

Apollos Academy exists to train ministry leaders to engage culture effectively. Through courses, conversations, and practical training, we’re helping pastors and ministry leaders understand the forces shaping our world so they can engage their communities more faithfully with the gospel.

Visit apolloswatered.org and sign up for our newsletter to be among the first to hear about Apollos Academy.

Stay Connected

If this conversation challenged your assumptions or helped you see the world differently, share it with a pastor, ministry leader, or friend.

Subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive, leave us a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and join our newsletter at apolloswatered.org.

Sign up for our newsletter

Order Travis’s book Blueprint: Kingdom Living in the Modern World.

Join Travis’s Substack, Deep Roots Society.

Donate to Apollos Watered and help make the Apollos Academy a reality!

Transcript
Travis Michael Fleming:

Today's episode is brought to you by the Waller family.

Zenas, I pray God blesses you a ton.

Peter Harrison:

Christianity is not an intellectual cop out.

And in fact, I think that for people who reflect.

And this is not to say that I think atheists or the non religious are stupid.

I don't think that there are good reasons for people to have significant religious doubts, and the problem of evil would be the most obvious.

But I think that not notwithstanding that Christianity is really an intellectually respectable tradition.

In addition, I think, of course, to answering the deep questions that all of us have.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Welcome to Ministry Deep Dive, where we go beneath the surface to understand the forces shaping our world, our churches and our lives so that we can engage our culture more faithfully with the gospel.

But let me begin with a question.

Why is it that in much of the modern Western world, believing in God is often regarded as something that requires an explanation, while not believing in God is increasingly treated as the reasonable or natural position?

Why do we assume that science deals with what is real, while religion deals primarily with what people believe?

And why do so many Christians, even those who firmly believe in God, seem to live much of their lives as though God is absent from the ordinary workings of the world?

We tend to assume that this is simply the way things are.

But what if the very categories that we use to understand faith, reason, nature and the supernatural are themselves products of a particular history?

What if our understanding of reality has been shaped by developments that most of us know almost nothing about?

That's where today's conversation takes us.

My guest is Peter Harrison, one of the world's leading historians of science and religion.

He is emeritus professor of History and philosophy at the University of Queensland and formerly held the Andreas Idrios Chair in Science and Religion at the University of Oxford.

latest, this book came out in:

Some new myths of Supernatural Belief in a Secular Age, published by Cambridge University Press, is a remarkable examination of how the modern Western world came to understand belief, reason, and the supernatural.

This is a challenging book, but it raises questions of enormous importance for pastors, ministry leaders, and anyone seeking to understand the culture in which we are called to bear witness to Christ.

So, Peter, welcome to Ministry Deep Dive.

Peter Harrison:

Right.

Thanks, Travis.

It's to be on the show and I look forward to the conversation.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay.

Are you ready for the Fast five?

Peter Harrison:

Well, I'm not sure, but let's give it a shot.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay.

These are just quick ones.

You'll handle this?

No problem.

If you can write this, you can handle these questions.

Okay.

All right, let's have some fun.

So what's one fun activity you did when you were a kid?

Peter Harrison:

A fun activity?

Look, to be honest, reading was a fun activity for me.

That sounds very nerdy, but anyway, I'll run with that.

Travis Michael Fleming:

No, that's fine.

I don't mind.

I enjoyed reading as a kid, too, so we're all good there.

But let me get to this, because you are in Australia.

I know this, but you have to tell me.

I'm an 80s kid, so you gotta tell me this.

Is Crocodile Dundee real?

Peter Harrison:

No.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I'm just messing with you.

That's not one of the questions I just had to ask.

Peter Harrison:

Okay.

Most of us live in cities on the coast of Australia, and, you know, a lot of us have never actually seen a crocodile.

But anyway, I suppose it's good for tourism, so.

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay.

Well, let's ask another kind of more introspective question.

What do you think?

Because you travel a lot around the world, you've taught in different cities, but what's the biggest difference you've seen between Australians and Americans?

Be honest.

Peter Harrison:

It's really.

It's a good question.

I think Australians and Americans often assume that they're much more alike than they really are.

And I think Australians are much more like Europeans and, of course, much more like Brits, partly, I think.

I mean, religion plays a huge role still, I think, in American culture in a way, that's not the case for Australia.

And so the conversation around things like science and religion has a very different sort of complexion, I think.

And, you know, honestly, what's happening over there at the moment, the politics of America is just crazy for us.

No one can believe what is happening in your country, if I may say so.

So.

Travis Michael Fleming:

I can't believe it either.

And I'm here.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

Right.

So, yeah, there you go.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, let me ask this question then.

Being an Australian then means what?

Give me a word.

Peter Harrison:

I think it means being on the fringes of a lot of activities, which I think is a great thing, because you kind of look from the outside to some extent, and we're a long, long way from everywhere.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Mm.

Okay.

All right, well, how about this question?

This will be the fifth of the Fast five.

One special talent that you have is what.

That nobody knows about.

Peter Harrison:

Right.

I'm a pretty.

Well, I played the guitar, I played in bands, and did session work earlier on in my career.

And that's kind of.

It's very much in the.

In the.

In the background.

But.

But actually, I'm.

I'm getting in much more into it now because I've got more.

A little bit more time on my hands to go and formally retired.

So.

Yeah,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

What kind of guitar are we talking about here?

Like Van Halen or what?

Peter Harrison:

I wouldn't aspire to that sort of level, but I played in rock bands.

But I play everything from classical to rock to jazz.

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Nice.

Okay then.

Well, that's awesome.

Well, let's get in.

We got to know you a little bit, but let's talk about your book, Some New World.

So this is the big question that we have.

This is an extraordinary work of scholarship.

It's really packed, and I want to make sure our listeners understand what prompted it.

What was the fundamental question you were trying to answer when you began writing Some New World?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, it's a good question, Travis.

Look, to be honest, there was a simple question that motivated it, and it's when did we, people in the west, start to think about a hard and fast distinction between the natural and the supernatural?

And what prompted that question was a realization that through my reading of pre modern writings of all kinds, I realized that there was.

There wasn't this distinction previously.

And when I read further, I realized that actually many other cultures don't observe this distinction between the supernatural and the natural.

So I was interested to find out how we came to make this distinction between these two kinds of realms and then crucially, how this distinction informs all of our discussions about various religious phenomena, from, you know, how science works to what miracles are, to how we think about indigenous and traditional forms of knowledge.

But as I say, the basic question was to think about essentially the relativity and the newness of this concept, natural versus supernatural, that we just take for granted and we think is kind of stamped on reality.

Travis Michael Fleming:

But it's not, as you mentioned, the indigenous cultures.

When you interact with people from indigenous cultures, you really have a difficult time talking because you find that science is so much in the background and assumed in our understanding of things that it does separate that supernatural and the world has changed.

But if we could just for a moment, if we could do a thought experiment here, if we could somehow transport a Christian living in the 13th century into a modern Western city today, what would be the most surprising to that person about how we understand the world?

Peter Harrison:

I think it would be.

The way in which all of our branches of knowledge are essentially isolated and siloed from each other.

And so that we don't seem to have a coherent overarching framework that makes sense of all of their relations to each other.

And that applies especially to, you know, another way of putting this is to say there's a sacred secular distinction.

And our conception of how causes operate in the world is one that's very, very much closed down and mechanical.

And what that means is that any kind of religious experience is typically regarded as some kind of incursion from without.

It's out of the ordinary.

And I think for our medieval predecessors that the operations of the spiritual and God were kind of incorporated into their daily lives in a relatively unexceptional.

And so that's one big difference, I think.

I guess the other one would be the way in which we tend to construct our religious convictions in terms of specific beliefs and practices.

And I think for medieval people, they were much more taken for granted, but incorporated into the rhythms of their rhythms, the very rhythms of their existence.

Travis Michael Fleming:

But now, of course, we're separated from that.

And I think many of us assume that a lot of our understanding of reality is simply common sense today.

But isn't part of your argument that what we consider common sense is actually the product of a very particular historical development?

Peter Harrison:

That's right.

Which is to say that things we take for granted and various concepts that we take for granted, the universality of something called religion, how we understand beliefs, as I said, this two tiered understanding of reality as natural and supernatural, we think that's just obvious.

And it is part of the conceptual suit that we swim in.

But what the history shows is that people in the past didn't think in these terms.

And I say so Christianity is a viable and living option without operating with what we regard as this fundamental distinction to, you know, something fundamental for how we understand religion, that it involves belief in the supernatural.

And I think for our medieval predecessors and for early Christians, their convictions were not understood in terms of specific beliefs in something like a supernatural realm now.

So that's significant.

And to go back to your previous point about when we converse with people from indigenous cultures, the other aspect that I've attempted to address in the book is our assumption that the position we now hold in terms of, with this conceptual apparatus that we have about natural and supernatural, that this represents progress and.

And what I think motivates that belief that we're in some sense in a superior position to people in the past and people in other cultures is largely to do with the success of science.

And we think that science is really based on this distinction, that science focuses on the natural and it excludes the supernatural.

So part of the package is not merely understanding how historically we came to have this quite aberrant conceptual distinction, the natural and the Supernatural, but that our conviction is that our progress depends on our progress as a kind of Western civilization depends on observing that distinction.

And the science, crucially, depends on it as well.

So science is the marker of progress, and science relies on this distinction.

And that's what makes us, in a sense, culturally and intellectually superior to what came before and, indeed, to certain cultures around us.

Travis Michael Fleming:

So in order to understand how we got here, we need to understand something about the way our language and our categories have changed.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah,.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Right.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

Yeah.

So, yeah.

And, Travis, I think the point here is that because we have a range of concepts that we just kind of take for granted, that we don't realize that they have a history and that they came into existence at a certain historical moment, and then we don't understand the significance of that.

And I think this applies to a range of the concepts that we use to think about Christianity and, indeed, religion in general, and religion is one of them.

So, for example, the first Christians and medieval thinkers didn't tend to think of themselves as subscribing to Christianity as a religion.

But as it relates to the point at hand, the concept I'm interested in the book is in the natural supernatural distinction.

And although we just think this is an obvious way of dividing up reality, in fact, when we look at our own history, and indeed if we look at other traditions, what we find is that this distinction is quite exceptional and that it's not something that people have believed in for the whole of history.

And we can isolate moments in history when this divide between natural and supernatural starts to develop.

We only find the words really in the Western tradition in the 13th century in any significant way, and it's only in the 17th century to the 19th century, is that this natural supernatural distinction starts to firm up in any significant way.

And what I've argued is that this actually makes a difference, that religious believers manage to think about their faith in ways that didn't involve this distinction.

And it actually makes a difference to how we conceptualise what Christianity and, indeed, what other religious traditions are about.

And I think, crucially, it also helps us understand some of the problems we encounter with a scientific, naturalistic understanding of the world and its relation to religious conviction.

So to go back to your point, yes, it's important to understand that some of the things that we just take for granted, some of the concepts and distinctions that we take for granted, actually have a history, and that history makes a key difference to how we think about fundamental issues.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Okay.

One of the things that struck me in your book as you're talking about.

This was your examination of the concept of belief itself.

Today we tend to think a belief of accepting certain propositions is true.

But you suggest that this isn't necessarily how Christians throughout history understood faith.

Can you unpack that just for a little bit for us?

Peter Harrison:

That's right, yes.

And, Travis, you've already alluded to one of the difficulties because you started speaking about belief and you ended up talking about faith.

And as you know, in the New Testament, the word for faith is pistis, but it's translated as both faith and belief.

And interestingly, in the first English translations, there's very little talk about belief, that the word is typically translated faith.

But owing to a series of complicated linguistic accidents to do with differences between, say, Greek and Latin and English, the single word pistis in Greek was represented in two different Latin words, and it's represented in two different English words, faith and belief.

And we tend to make a distinction between faith and belief.

In German, actually, you can't make that distinction terribly easily still.

So it reflects the original Greek.

But enough about the linguistic side of things.

If we look at the way in which this word pistis in Greek faith is used in the New Testament and its equivalents in the Old Testament, the key references are to trust.

It means trust.

And although I'm not a New Testament scholar, I'm a historian, I think that New Testament scholarship is there's a strong consensus about this.

Epistis in the New Testament refers to trust in God in essence than what we would regard as agreeing with a set of propositions.

And so the interesting thing is, how do we go from a conception of faith as trust to something more like what we now think of belief as assenting to certain propositions.

And so part of the story of the book is to trace how historically that change has taken place.

Now, I should say in all of this, the point here is not that.

The point here is not that Christianity doesn't involve conviction that certain things are true.

And obviously, you know, to take a very simple case, the creeds and the symbols of the church set out what things Christians believe to be true.

And so certainly there is a sense in which belief does involve.

It's not just a feeling, I suppose, is what I.

It does involve belief in something.

Trust in something requires belief that certain things are true and those certain things are entailed in the creed.

But we lose something in translation when we think belief or faith.

Let's go back to faith.

Faith is simply to be understood in terms of a form of knowing particular Things rather than an attitude of trust.

And when we track in the New Testament and in the writings of the Church Fathers and in medieval thinkers what they understood faith to entail, trust is far and away the most predominant element, as opposed to intellectual assent to certain propositions.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, let's continue on that line, because we live today in a culture that often says, I'll believe it when you prove it to me.

How did we arrive at the assumption that religious belief must be justified primarily through evidence and rational argument?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

So, again, Travis, the story is a long and complicated one.

I think a key.

As you'll know from the book, I think a key moment is the Protestant Reformation.

And up until this period, there was a very strong.

There was a concept called implicit belief.

And the idea of implicit belief, going back to this question of trust, was that for most people, understanding the intricacies of the doctrine of the Trinity, or how the two natures of Christ are related in the Incarnation, that was beyond most people.

But what was important is that they had trust that the Church had worked it out and the Church had got the intellectual side of it right.

And so this idea was called implicit belief, that for the laity, for the most part, they simply needed to trust that the Church had got it right, and that's their faith in the Holy Roman and Apostolic Church and so on.

Trust that the Church has got the doctrine, the doctrinal side of things tied up.

When the Protestant Reformation comes along, we have a problem because we no longer have a single overarching ecclesiastical authority.

We have competing forms of authority.

So it's no longer possible for people simply to have implicit faith in a single institution, because there are institutions arguing for different doctrinal interpretations.

And as a consequence of this, then we need an alternative criterion to judge doctrinal content.

We simply can't trust authority because we now have competing authorities.

And it's at this point, I think, that notions of an instrumental reason or a form of logic enables us to then make judgments about the validity of doctrinal claims.

And so we end up with what's called an ethics of belief.

The idea, and we see this in Martin Luther and John Calvin, that people need to take responsibility for themselves to be able to justify the beliefs that they hold.

And that's a big change from implicit belief.

But at that point, then we have the necessity for a certain form of argumentation or rationalisation or a rational working out of how we adjudicate between competing religious claims.

And that makes a big change, for better or worse, in how we understand the nature of belief.

And that's part of what I think involves a move from.

From faith as trust to faith and belief as having a being able to justify the propositions that you hold to be true.

Now, and the flow on effect then, is that this then starts to apply to all forms of knowledge.

And so we have, you know, science, I think, presents itself as the key exemplification of this notion of beliefs being provable and justifiable.

To go back to your point about, I won't believe it until you prove it to me, but I would say in all of this, what we tend to forget is that the crucial role that trust still plays in all of our networks of knowledge, first and foremost in the sciences, where individual scientists have to rely on what other people are telling them because it's a communal activity and the knowledge is spread across the scientific community.

And this is why cases of scientific fraud are so damaging for the sciences, because although we tend to think about rational knowledge as being to do with, I can justify rationally all of the beliefs I hold, the reality is, even for the most elevated aspect of our knowledge, which is the natural sciences, the role of trust is pervasive and it's crucial to the whole operation.

And that really is no different, I would argue, from the implicit faith that Christians typically had, that the institutions, that.

That they're part of the institutions, that the authority of the knowledge ultimately resides institutionally, communally, it's distributed.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Which is one of the difficulties that we see today is people are losing their trust in institutions because of scandal or because of things within America.

What we see, just, again, looking at it from a cultural standpoint, when Covid came out, there was a lot of distrust over what was being told.

Some of that was justified, some of it was not.

But even then into the whole.

The transgender phenomenon, and we don't need to go into that, but there's a part where it's like, you have scientists that basically say certain things, and you have people going, my common sense says no.

And so you're seeing this juxtaposition where people are, in some respect, are losing trust in science, but they don't know what to trust now at all.

And that's the question as we get into this.

So I just find your argument, your thesis, very compelling, but it takes you down.

I mean, you pull that string and it starts going everywhere.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, now that's exactly right, Travis.

And I think your point about trust in institutions, and there's interesting work done on this, and you're exactly right to say that it's characteristic of the 21st century that people in the west are increasingly losing trust in institutions.

And we used to think, we used to have this fairly simple divide that, you know, people stop trusting in religious.

Religious authorities, and they replaced that with a trust in scientific authorities.

And I think there's an element of truth to that.

But your point about COVID I think, is really interesting.

And I think there was something of a, you know, something of an important historical moment there where, partly because people's faith in science was, in a sense, unrealistic, and Covid showed the kind of human side of the sciences where scientists frankly, didn't know, and often they presented as if they did.

And this led people to realize that science was, like all of our human activities, science was a fallible activity.

Now, you know, what's happened as a consequence of this, I think, is that they tend to throw the baby out with the bath water.

But what I think is at fault there is that people had an unrealistic expectation of what they could expect from the relevant sciences.

And that scientists, to be frank, many of them didn't do themselves a particular favor because they wanted to go along with the notion about, you know, the infallible authority of the sciences.

And what we discovered is that.

And I don't.

Let me be clear here, I think science in relation to our health is probably the best thing we've got going.

Let's be clear about that.

I'm not going to be typically running up against a scientific consensus, but the sciences are more fallible than we often think.

And Covid was an interesting moment where I think people, in a very practical way, came to realise for the first time the extent to which there's the operation of faith and trust that's required for us to accept the deliverances of the sciences as well.

Travis Michael Fleming:

That's one of the surprising elements that.

That I find in retrospect.

I look back and in the us, in the world, that the people that I interact with there were one of two responses.

There was the implicit acceptance of it, the trust in it, and then there was the rejection where they didn't trust science.

And I just saw that one or the other.

It was very interesting, even now in retrospect, to see some have both kind of shifted in some respect.

But it's a fascinating phenomenon because what I really found interesting in your book was how much of the scientific development and our understanding of science had a philosophical foundation that really was like, well, wait a minute, I guess, and suppose that that is how it's come to be, but I'd never thought of it in those terms.

And there is a degree of faith even in science, correct?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, absolutely.

And so, you know, what if we go back to the scientific revolution, the 17th century, when essentially modern science is getting up and running, I think we can say two things that I think are often surpr and the first is that science received its social legitimacy from appealing to religion.

So it wasn't obvious in the 17th century that science was going to turn into this wonderful authoritative thing.

Scientists, in order to get experimental science up and running, appealed to its, first of all, its religious foundations.

And it required religious assumptions about how God operates in the world.

The regularities of the natural world, laws of nature, as a theological conception experiment is based on particular religious convictions about our experience.

So the whole foundations of the modern sciences are actually theological.

And so one, you know, if we come back to the present, one argument might be that lacking when people no longer subscribe to the theological convictions that gave science its original grounding and its social legitimacy, then the authority of science falls into question again.

So that's one aspect of it.

And I think the other thing that's surprising is the way in which people fail to understand science as a communal activity.

And so that what happen is that the idea of implicit faith that operates within Christianity, that talks, that requires trust in an institution that actually transfers to scientific organizations.

Society, which was founded in:

And what we see there, if we look at the sociology of it, is that you have a group of individuals who have to trust each other's experimental reports, and they build on these.

But there's an operation of implicit faith going on right there.

And, you know, the bottom line then is that all of our institutions of knowledge, whether we are conscious of it or not, require some degree of faith in the sense of trust.

And it's often operating at this implicit level.

And what happened in the COVID moment is that these elements of faith bubble to the surface and people realize just how much trust is involved in accepting the deliverances of the sciences.

And so part of my point, understanding the history of these institutions, but also understanding the key role that trust still plays if our institutions are going to work at all.

And that's true for both the religious traditions and the scientific tradition.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, let's slightly change gears.

We've talked a lot about faith trust.

We talked about this a little bit bit ago where we talked about the natural and the supernatural.

But I think that this might surprise many of our listeners because you Argue, and as you said at the beginning of this, that our modern distinction between the natural and the supernatural is relatively recent.

And most Christians today assume the distinction has always existed.

What are we missing?

Peter Harrison:

Well, look, I think, you know, we're missing quite a few things.

I think one natural tendency, I think.

I think for modern people like us, we just take these concepts for granted.

And more than that, I think we project them back onto the past.

And so when we read the New Testament, we tend to read it through the lens of this natural supernatural distinction.

Now, part of what makes this possible, I think, is the fact that there is something like that distinction operative.

And it's a distinction between the Creator and the created.

And that is an important distinction.

But we need to understand that this distinction between God and his creation does not map onto a distinction between the natural and the supernatural.

And, you know, to go to the difference it makes, I think, you know, there's a couple of ways we can think about this.

Let's think about it in terms, say, of laws of nature.

So laws of nature, like the natural supernatural distinction, is a very modern idea, comes into existence in the 17th century, where for the key thinkers, laws of nature are laws that God imposes on the world.

They're to do with the will of God.

And pretty much everyone says this.

Descartes, the French philosopher, is the first to come up with it.

But the English natural philosophers, the English scientists like Robert Boyle, Isaac Newton, the astronomer Johannes Kepler, they all argue that laws of nature is just the will of God operating in the natural world.

And this view of laws of nature persists until the 19th century.

Now, if we ask the question, are laws of nature natural?

Well, they're of nature and they pertain to nature.

But insofar as for these thinkers, laws of nature is just God imposing his will.

It's completely supernatural to that extent.

And the point here is that laws of nature as they were understood when they were first formulated by these first scientists, are intrinsically supernatural.

Now, what happens in the 19th century is that a group of scientific naturalists who want to argue that there is no supernatural, they simply take this idea of laws of nature and they say this is a brute feature of reality.

We don't need to explain where laws of nature came from.

They are just purely natural.

And if you ask a contemporary naturalist what their convictions are, they'll say essentially the only things that exist are natural and there is no supernatural.

That's only possible when you have an idea of the natural and the supernatural, as opposed.

Once you look at the History, you'll understand that there was no opposition between them in terms of a concept like laws of nature, which was at once both ultimately and 100% supernatural and 100% natural.

So that's just one example of the way in which the concept has implications.

There's one other one that I think it's a little bit more difficult to get up, but it's to do with the operation of our minds.

And for thinkers from ancient philosophers through the Church fathers, the belief, I think, that our capacity to know anything at all is really a function of God operating in our minds.

Augustine has this famous idea, the Church, father Augustine for 5th century, famous idea that we know things when God illuminates our minds with the truth.

And there was a long standing belief then that the only reason we had confidence in our intellectual powers was that there was something supernatural about how they operated, that we were somehow getting in touch with ultimate reality.

Now, again, with the rise of naturalism, our minds become part of the natural world, which then I think raises the question of why would we reside confidence that our cognitive powers are actually in touch with reality anymore?

And, you know, there are interesting arguments mounted by philosophers like Alvin Plantinger, who wants to say that an evolutionary naturalism is incompatible with our actually being able to assert any truth about the world.

Because on a purely naturalistic understanding of the operations of our minds, we have no reason to be confident that they're yielding anything true about the world.

And so again, I think it's interesting if we go right back to the origins of modern science in the 17th century in relation to this world, these questions of the natural and the supernatural.

That dichotomy wasn't really in operation in relation both to the laws of the natural world, how they operate, and the laws of how our own minds operate to intuit the nature of reality.

Travis Michael Fleming:

There's so much there that you're giving us.

There's a lot.

Here's another question though.

Peter Harrison:

Sure.

Travis Michael Fleming:

There is this unexpected genealogy of secularism that you bring about.

And there's a paradox because really Christianity has actually helped shape the secular age.

Right.

I mean, many Christians assume that secularism developed when the west began rejecting Christianity.

But your work suggests that some of the intellectual foundations of modern secularism actually emerge from within theological developments.

How should we understand that?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, so thanks for making that point, Travis.

Yeah, look, I think this goes right, it goes right back.

I mean, I think the scientific revolution of the 17th century is key, but I think it goes right back to Judaism and Christian monotheism.

And you often get the story that, you know, well, you often, yeah, there's a pop version of history that says, you know, the Greeks had science and they were doing really well.

Then Christianity came along and killed it off.

And then only in the 17th century did we start to get things back on track.

Now that has it absolutely back to Frank.

So what happens, I think, when Christianity appears on the scene?

The German philosopher Hegel has a very brief saying that Christianity fell the sacred groves and it silenced the muses.

And so Christianity has a naturalizing effect insofar as the belief in a single creator banishes all of the spirits and all of the minor gods from the world.

So Christianity already in the first century is a force for a kind of desacralization, a kind of demagic, takes them some of the magic out of the world.

And this was the reason that the first Christians were called atheists.

They didn't believe in all of these traditional gods of the Romans and the Greeks.

And so that Christianity already has this effect of restricting the channels of divine action in the world to this single, essentially, to this single channel.

So there's a tendency already for Judaism and Christianity, insofar as they're strictly monotheistic, to reduce the operations of spirits and minor gods in the world.

In the 17th century, this gets an extra boost from Protestantism.

And Protestantism wants to restrict, you know, the operations of the supernatural even further.

And we see this, for example, you know, one simple.

A simple example would be Protestants insistence that there are only two sacraments, there are only two, or in the case of Luther, occasionally with three.

And so this reduces the channels of the operations of sacramental grace.

Protestantism wants to argue that the priests don't have this magic function of being able to conduct transubstantiation.

The Protestants are very strongly critical of contemporary Catholic miracles.

So the standard, although Protestants do, in reality, you know, there's miracles going on all over the place.

But the official line was miracles stopped at the end of the apostolic age.

And so that we don't see miracles being performed on a daily basis, Catholics argued that we did and that this was part of the vindication of the Catholic tradition.

So in these different ways, what Protestantism does is it further restricts and secularises and naturalises what's going on in the natural world, carrying on that tradition from the strict monotheism of Christianity and Judaism, going right back to the first century.

And in a sense, then the 19th century emergence of a naturalism just goes one step further and it says we're actually going to take God out of the picture.

But in fact, what the move is in the 19th century is simply to redescribe laws of nature as purely naturalistic.

Whereas the traditional understanding from the 17th to the 19th century had been laws of nature.

Nature is God directly acting in the world.

And so in the 19th century, we simply have this one further step.

It's a kind of ultra Protestantism, as I say in the book Protestantism on Steroids, that actually now removes God from the picture so that all you're left with is nature.

So my argument is that secularization is, in essence, it's a.

It's a Christian phenomenon, but taken in the form of naturalism, taken one step further.

But that one step further, I think, problematically takes all of the rationale and logic out of our understanding of how the natural world is rationally structured and ordered.

And so what you get with naturalism, then, is an assertion of a particular understanding of reality, but with.

Without the presuppositions and assumptions that would make that a logical position to hold.

Travis Michael Fleming:

With that in mind, you're talking about this naturalism that's developed, but simultaneously we've inherited a story that says humanity once lived in an age of superstition, then science and reason liberated us, and we gradually became enlightened.

But what's historically wrong with that story?

And why has that become so powerful in the modern Western imagination?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, so look, I think that second question is a really interesting question, Travis, and I'm not sure I've completely, completely worked it out.

But let me go back to the basic, you know, the history that Enlightenment propagandists push and that we see this emphasized not merely in the age of enlightenment, in the 18th century, but also in the age of scientific naturalization.

Naturalism in the 19th century is a kind of invented history that wants to say that this naturalistic view of the world is utterly opposed to religious conceptions of the operations of nature.

And my argument is that it's far more complicated than that insofar as the operations of nature were for thousands of years understood as being underpinned by divine activity.

So the question is, you know, where does this story come from?

About, we've overcome this age of superstition and moved into an age of reason.

And again, it comes back to Protestant critiques of Catholicism, because the Protestant.

The proto Protestant history.

So what happens in the Protestant Reformation and the Catholic Reformation is you get competing histories, and the Catholics want to argue that they are the legitimate heirs of the apostolic tradition, and the Protestants have to argue that Catholicism was a diversion away from, you know, pure and original Christianity that Protestantism is now bringing us back to.

So you've got those competing historical versions of what's going on.

But the Protestant story is essentially that Catholicism degenerates into miracle mongering, superstition, priestcraft, etc.

Etc.

So the Protestant story in its basic plot lines is the story of modernity.

And what happens is that Enlightenment thinkers in the 18th century look at these Protestant histories of Catholicism that constructed is this corrupt, superstitious, priest ridden corruption.

And they simply apply that to the whole of history and with one edition they kind of secularise it.

So the Enlightenment stories are directly the Enlightenment stories of our history.

This liberation from religious superstition and moving to an age of light and reason are really just adapted from a Protestant apologetic history that's anti Catholic.

And interestingly, even the imagery is the same.

And so the motto of Geneva, for example, Protestant Reformation Geneva was lightness after dark.

So the Protestant Reformation constructed itself as an age of light after the darkness of medieval superstition.

And Enlightenment apologists just picked up that narrative and said, thank you very much, we'll have that and we're gonna use it for our story about the emancipation of the human race from this oppressive religious picture.

And again then, so we can say that this naturalistic, secularist outlook is a kind of development of Protestantism.

It's just the next step.

Travis Michael Fleming:

You know, I find funny as we're talking about Protestantism versus Catholicism.

I was in Egypt several years ago and I was interacting with a pastor from the United States went in, a Jewish Egyptian came up to us and he wanted to know what we were talking about.

And we were having a religious conversation.

And he said, are you religious?

We said yes.

He goes, well, what kind of religion are you?

We said, well, we're Christians.

And he goes, okay, what kind of Christians are you?

And at the time we just said evangelical just because this was kind of this group and now it has much more of a political connotation.

And he goes, what's that?

He had no idea what that was.

And I said, well, we're Protestants.

I was thinking the next category up.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

And he said, he goes, what's that?

And I said we broke off from Roman Catholicism.

And he goes, they were wrong from the beginning.

And he was Coptic.

So our Orthodox friends are sitting on the sideline going, this is a Catholic and a Protestant thing.

We've had it the entire time.

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

No, it's very interesting that we often leave the Orthodox and the cops out of the picture.

But if you going right back to faith as trust, I think interesting.

I think the Eastern Orthodox traditions have maintained much more of that.

But again, interestingly, in relation to science, we don't see science tending to flourish or emerge out of those Orthodox traditions.

It's very characteristic of the West.

And so there's something, I think there's something to that story, and we've often thought in the west that this is a function of our Western superiority.

But I suppose what I'm trying to say is part of the question is, have we lost something in the context of developing this wonderful rat nationalistic scientific approach to the world?

And, you know, let me just say two things.

I don't want to be seen to be criticizing Protestantism.

And you know, I'm not advocating for Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy in relation to Protestantism.

And I think the key thing is, to use the expression of the historian Brad Gregory, Protestantism has unintended consequences.

And a lot of history is about things that happen as a consequence of an event, but that were never intended by the key actors in the event.

And so the story I'm telling is not, oh, Protestantism is to blame for the desacralization and secularization of the world any more than Christianity is, although I think that Christianity and Protestantism provided the occasion for these things to take place.

Travis Michael Fleming:

It is fascinating to me when I interact with people from majority world cultures, and I find that it's easier to communicate for me biblical truth to them because their worldview, they never passed through the Enlightenment, they never passed through the Industrial Revolution, they never passed through the Protestant Reformation, that what they've received is, in some respect, they're in a very similar cultural framework that Jesus was in.

So I just find it interesting that it seems like in some respect we're trying to unlearn, like we're trying to learn, but we're trying to unlearn what some of the negative collateral damage has been for some of these questions.

Am I wrong in that?

Peter Harrison:

No, no, look, I think that's exactly right, Travis.

And look, part of the, you know, the dilemma I think we face is that what modernity and the Enlightenment and science has delivered has in many respects been wonderful and terrific.

And I wouldn't want to go back to the Middle Ages in many respects.

And indeed, the same is true, I think, for other cultures.

But as you say, collateral, I think, is a key way of thinking about it.

Along with these advantages, we've got things that we've often not thought about that aren't Necessarily as helpful as we might have thought.

And so the dilemma we wrestle with is, you know, do we go back to the Middle Ages?

Well, no, that's not even a realistic.

That's not a realistic option, and it's probably not a desirable option.

But how, in this contemporary secular, scientific world that we live in, do we still draw on those resources from the past, which were so important for people then and should be important for us now, without at the same time denying the things that science and, you know, an Enlightenment secular approach that the world has delivered?

So, I mean, to give you, you know, America is the classic case of this.

People can practice.

They're free to practice any religious tradition they want.

I think that's a good thing.

I think that's a consequence of the Protestant Reformation and the Enlightenment.

But at the same time, that also has a kind of leveling effect on all religious conditions.

In some sense, we think they're all the same.

So it's really a question of attempting to understand that there is a downside.

There is a downside, and to see if there are ways in which we can ameliorate that or compensate for it.

And your point about talking to people in other cultures, and my point as a historian would be looking back to see how people in the past thought about things.

Both of these are really, I think, key resources for thinking about that question.

Question.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Part of what we do is we talk about Leslie Newbegin.

I don't know if you're familiar with his work, but was a missionary to India for many years and talked about a missionary encounter with Western culture.

And one of the things that really, for us plays a role in the missionary encounter is understanding history, meaning that how did we get to where we're at, as well as understanding the global church and allowing them to speak into us, to notice our blind spots.

And I am noticing, though, a resurgence.

And I know you're a historian.

Things are happening, happening in real time.

But I feel like there's this new movement where people are saying, I'm tired of this.

I don't see the world in that way anymore.

I do think that the biblical worldview is much more of this integrated.

I hate to use natural and supernatural categories, but you're seeing, to me, this a new awakening to the unseen realm, let's say.

Do you see any of that in your research?

Or have you heard of any of that coming back out now?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah, I think so, Travis.

And look, I think there are a number of things motivating this, and one I think is an impending ecological catastrophe and people realizing the way in which science and technology are kind of implicated in that.

And so that's.

So people have no interest in religion in particular.

That really helps focus the mind, I think.

And so that is, I think one factor.

I think another factor is that, you know, the sacred never really went away.

It migrated into other places.

And so I think, you know, there's a persistence of the sacred, and it's just.

It doesn't necessarily appear in the context of organized.

The organized religions that we're familiar with.

And so people like Jamie Smith and Bill Kavanaugh have argued about, you know, how secular liturgies.

And so we get the migration of the sacred into these other spaces where it kind of, to put it pejoratively, you know, it's a kind of idolatrous form of what was once a particular religious tradition.

So, yes to that.

Another motivating factor is that people in academe have become re interested in indigenous traditions and to some extent, attempting to incorporate them into the curriculum.

But that turns out to be impossible to do from a purely naturalistic perspective because these other traditions don't subscribe to that.

Although I think the realization has been slow to dawn.

It's there.

And just one other kind of, you know, Straw in the Wind books.

I don't know if, you know, Carlos Ayres book called they Flew, which is.

It's about reports of the miraculous in the past.

And this was something historians were really reluctant to touch.

But what he.

What this book, He's a historian at Yale, and it's a really interesting book that I hadn't read before I wrote mine, unfortunately.

But what he argues is the empirical evidence for what we regard as miraculous is historically so strong that you really just can't simply dismiss it.

Now, his book has been, I think, controversial in some respects, but it's an attempt from a serious historian to say this Protestant outright dismissal of miracle reports.

We just can't run with that anymore because the historical evidence is too strong.

And whether this is going to be a tradition in academe, I don't know.

But what it suggests is that there are from various sources, there's a chipping away at the dominant academic narrative that everything is purely naturalistic.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, I think that part of that, as you've.

You've talked about, that this came out of the Protestant Reformation, primarily the Latin Western church in the Latin Western categories.

But with globalization and pluralization that we see going on, we're interacting with people from different cultures.

We just don't have categories for their worldview and they don't fit our naturalistic view.

And I think it's a corrective.

Personally, as a pastor and coming from a church where my church was multi ethnic and from a journey world culture, I saw that firsthand.

So as we're talking about this though, and this is what I find in your final chapter, you ask why people in other times and cultures perceive a world filled with these spiritual realities while modern Westerns often don't.

Although I think that's changing.

Why do you think people now are, are hungering for this and they're rejecting and I know not all, and it's still within an academic community, but you're seeing at least an interest in it.

Why do you think that's the case?

Peter Harrison:

Look, I think for some of the reasons I think we've already discussed, but I think ultimately people realize that in this purely stripped down naturalistic world you can't find meaning and you can distract yourself from that and you can find amusing things to do.

But ultimately, deep down, I think people search for meaning and what they find is that their search for meaning is not being satisfied by the dominant paradigms of purely secular naturalism, that there's just nothing there that answers for them this existential quest for a meaningful life.

And you know, I think we've been slow to realize that in the west and we've assumed that the sciences actually are the sciences what warrant this approach.

And this is why I'm interested partly to say no, the sciences do not warrant this approach.

And because I think while people hold to this view that sciences give legitimacy to this purely naturalistic, reductionistic world, that they might like it, but they need to face up to the reality, even though so the meaningless world is unfortunate, but really science tells us that's what there is.

So we just need to explain accepted.

And part of what I'm attempting to do is to pull apart the nexus between the natural sciences and this fairly bleak outlook on life, such that people no longer assume that they have to accept it because the most authoritative forms of our knowledge, the sciences, give it legitimacy.

And I don't think that's the case.

Now here again, I don't want to say, you know, I'm advocating some form of science skepticism, but I think it's rather a matter of understanding what it is that the sciences deliver to us and what they don't deliver to us.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, I had mentioned Newbegin and I want to pull that thread, if I might continue, because he argued that the modern Western worldview had become so deeply embedded in our culture that people were often unaware of its underlying assumptions.

So in some ways, your book seems to provide a historical account of how these assumptions emerge.

So here's my question.

If we're going to eng modern Western culture with the Christian faith, do we need to do more than simply present evidence for Christian beliefs?

Do we need also need to challenge the underlying understanding of reality that determines what modern people consider believable in the first place?

Peter Harrison:

Yeah.

So two things.

Two things, Travis.

First, I think it's a case as.

I don't know if you Americans have this saying, horses for courses, but it means that you need to adapt what you need to, in a sense, in this context, you need to adapt your message for your own audience.

And there are people for whom I think rational apologetic arguments work.

And for those people, I think what's needed is a set of rational apologetic arguments, at least I think in the negative sense, arguments that pull apart the assumptions that underpin their worldview.

So I do think there's a place for that.

But ultimately, I think it's not at the level of argumentation that these things operate and that it's.

Unless people come to the realisation for themselves that they have a need that's not being satisfied by the current views they hold.

And I think many people are in that position.

What they need to be assured about is that there's nothing that Christian faith is intellectually respectable.

And I think that the position we're in today is that many people say, my colleagues in academe, for example, just don't think it's a serious option intellectually, that it's something.

It's a bit of a crime.

And so what I hope, you know, my work does, and I know the work of others, is many Christian scholars is to say, actually, no, Christianity is part of a long, long tradition, intellectual tradition, and it's a long, intellectually respectable tradition.

And again, interestingly, in relation to the sciences, the vast majority of leading scientists have had religious convictions.

That's changed only in the last, say, 100 years.

And we have to ask what's going on?

But sorry to go back to your point, then.

I'm personally not a big one for apologetics, but I do think there are people for whom those arguments work and who find them appealing.

But more generally, I think what I've attempted to do in my work, and I see this in the work of others, is to show that religious conviction can be intellectually honest, that it's rigorous, and indeed, I think it's more rigorous than the alternatives.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, I see your work in some respect, and I know it's an academic work, but to me it's in some respect a cultural apologetic.

It's different than traditional apologetics because cultural apologetics is really the work of establishing the Christian voice, conscience and imagination within a culture so that Christianity can be seen as true and satisfying.

And for me, that involves looking at the deep structures of culture to see how they affect the viability, communicability, and authenticity of the gospel message, both explicitly and implicitly.

And I think your work does just that.

But I understand, because I think today, and I was in a PhD course at one time, I remember sitting in there and the professor was talking about evidentiary apologetics, and I said, people today say fake news, fake news.

It doesn't play in the same way that it did a generation ago.

And our world has, our cultural topography has shifted.

And I think you've shown that it can't just be assumed any longer.

We need to check how we got those beliefs that we might think are just normal and natural.

Actually has a great deal of philosophy and view behind it.

There's a lot of history.

So thank you for that, really.

Peter Harrison:

Thanks.

Travis I'm glad that you see it because that's what I hoped for the book.

Yeah.

Travis Michael Fleming:

Well, let me just bring this kind of back in.

We've been meeting for a while and I know your time is short.

What then is one thing that you just like to leave with our audience?

Peter Harrison:

Travis I think it goes back to what I was just saying, that Christianity is not an intellectual cop out.

And in fact, I think that for people who reflect, and this is not to say that I think atheists or the non religious are stupid, I don't think that either.

I think there are good reasons for people to have significant religious doubts and the problem of evil would be the most obvious.

But I think that notwithstanding that, Christianity is really an intellectually respectable tradition.

In addition, I think, of course, to answering the deep questions that all of us have.

Travis Michael Fleming:

That's a good word to leave with us today.

Peter thank you for joining us today.

I appreciate not only the depth of your scholarship, your work challenges us to reconsider assumptions I think that we often take for granted.

Because one of the things that I hope our listeners take away from this conversation is that we don't simply look at the world as it is.

We look at it through categories, assumptions and perspectives that have been handed down to us.

And sometimes those assumptions are so deeply embedded in our thinking that we don't even realize they're there.

And for Christians, that's especially important.

If we're going to communicate the Gospel faithfully in our culture, we need to understand not only what people believe, but why certain things seem believable to them in the first place.

That's one of the reasons we do Ministry Deep Dive.

We want to help you go beneath the surface, understand the world in which God has placed you, and engage that world with biblical wisdom and missionary purpose.

So I encourage you to pick up Peter Harrison's book, Some New Myths of Supernatural Belief in a Secular Age, published by Cambridge University Press, and if this conversation has been helpful, please share it with a pastor, ministry leader, or someone who is wrestling with the relationship between faith and modern culture.

Be sure to subscribe to Ministry Deep Dive.

Leave us a review and sign up for our newsletter@apolloswater.org to stay connected with the conversations and resources we're developing.

Until next time.

Peter, thank you for being on Ministry Deep Dive.

Peter Harrison:

Thanks Travis.

It was a great pleasure talking with you.

Travis Michael Fleming:

What a fascinating conversation with Peter Harrison.

You know, one of the things I hope you take away from today's discussion is that we don't simply see the world as it is.

We see it through categories and assumptions that have been handed down to us, often without our realizing it.

And if we're going to engage our culture faithfully today with the Gospel, we need to understand not only what people believe, but why they believe it.

That's also why we're launching the Apollos Academy.

It's a brand new initiative dedicated to training ministry leaders like yourself to engage culture effectively with the gospel.

We want to equip pastors and ministry leaders to see beneath the the surface, understand the forces shaping our world, and lead their churches into a more faithful missionary encounter with their communities.

We're excited about what's coming and we'd love for you to be part of it.

Head over to ApolloSweater.org and sign up for our newsletter.

You'll hear more about Apollos Academy, upcoming conversations and resources we're developing.

And one more thing, if Ministry Deep Dive has been helping helpful to you, would you take a moment to rate and review the podcast on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen?

It really does help others discover these conversations.

Thanks for joining us today.

This is Travis Michael Fleming signing off from Apollo's Watered Stay Watered everybody.

Sam.